Is J.J. McCarthy the Vikings’ No. 1 QB? He’s Not So Sure

The Future of the Vikings’ Quarterback Position Remains Unclear

The Minnesota Vikings have a lot of excitement surrounding their future, but one major question remains unanswered: Is J.J. McCarthy the undisputed starting quarterback for the 2025 season? Despite the widespread belief that McCarthy, the 22-year-old rookie, is set to take the reins, the young signal-caller himself has admitted that he hasn’t been officially given the title of QB1.

A Revealing Interview with Kay Adams

During an interview with Kay Adams at the NFLPA golf tournament in Mexico, McCarthy addressed the speculation about his role. When asked when the Vikings informed him that he was the starting quarterback, his response raised eyebrows.

“Um, they haven’t told me,” McCarthy admitted. “I’m happy they didn’t because I’m trying to earn that every single day. I never want that to be given to me. It’s such a privilege and opportunity to give me that chance, and I’m just going to make the most of that every single day.”

That statement, while showcasing McCarthy’s humility and work ethic, also leaves the door open for speculation about Minnesota’s quarterback situation.

The Aaron Rodgers Rumors Won’t Die

McCarthy may be the presumed starter, but the Vikings have been linked to Aaron Rodgers for months. While recent reports indicate that Minnesota is no longer actively pursuing the four-time MVP, the door hasn’t been completely shut.

According to The Athletic’s Dianna Russini, Rodgers’ top choice was the Los Angeles Rams, but his second preference remains Minnesota. The Vikings’ front office, meanwhile, is still evaluating McCarthy’s performance in offseason workouts before finalizing their plans. If Rodgers were to remain available, could the Vikings still make a move?

For now, the prevailing belief is that Rodgers will end up in Pittsburgh, but until he officially signs elsewhere, the speculation will continue.

If Not Rodgers, Then Who?

Should Rodgers commit to another team, the Vikings may explore other veteran options to back up McCarthy. Names like Joe Flacco and Ryan Tannehill have been floated as possible contingency plans. While neither would be expected to challenge McCarthy for the starting job, they could serve as valuable insurance policies for a team looking to make a deep playoff run.

McCarthy’s Confidence in His Health and Readiness

Despite the uncertainty surrounding his role, McCarthy is feeling great physically. When asked about his health, he responded confidently.

“I would say I’m 100%, but staying consistent with the rehab process and not wavering from that and staying disciplined with all the outside stuff and making sure I’m not chopping too much wood and doing all that fun stuff.”

His response suggests that while he may still be in the recovery process, he feels fully capable of taking on the responsibility of leading the team.

The Vikings’ Quarterback Decision Looms

With training camp approaching, the Vikings have a critical decision to make. Will they fully commit to McCarthy as their starting quarterback, or will they keep their options open and consider a veteran addition? While McCarthy’s talent is undeniable, his inexperience leaves room for uncertainty.

The Vikings’ approach in the coming weeks will reveal whether they are truly ready to hand the keys to McCarthy or if they are still holding out for a potential blockbuster move. Until then, the quarterback drama in Minnesota remains one of the most intriguing storylines of the NFL offseason.