Chicago Cubs’ Pitching Solution: Triston McKenzie as a Potential Justin Steele Replacement
The Chicago Cubs are at a critical juncture in the 2025 MLB season, with their pitching rotation facing challenges due to potential injuries and inconsistent performances. Justin Steele, a cornerstone of the Cubs’ starting rotation, has been a reliable ace, but recent concerns about his availability have sparked discussions about potential replacements. While the Cubs were unable to secure a high-profile trade for Miami Marlins’ pitcher Sandy Alcantara, a new opportunity has emerged with the Cleveland Guardians’ decision to designate Triston McKenzie for assignment (DFA). This unexpected move could be the perfect chance for the Cubs to bolster their pitching staff and maintain their competitive edge in the National League Central. In this article, we’ll explore why McKenzie could be the ideal replacement for Steele, his potential impact on the Cubs, and what this means for the team’s postseason aspirations.
The Cubs’ Pitching Dilemma in 2025
The Chicago Cubs have shown promise in the 2025 season, with a balanced roster and a strong desire to return to the postseason. However, their pitching rotation has been a point of concern. Justin Steele, a left-handed pitcher known for his precision and ability to dominate hitters, has been a key figure in the Cubs’ success. His 2023 breakout season, where he posted a 3.06 ERA over 173.1 innings, solidified his role as the team’s ace. However, injuries and workload management have raised questions about his availability for the remainder of the 2025 campaign.
Without Steele, the Cubs’ rotation lacks the depth needed to compete against top-tier teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers or Philadelphia Phillies. While pitchers like Kyle Hendricks and Shota Imanaga have been reliable, the team needs another high-impact starter to maintain their momentum. The Cubs’ front office, led by Jed Hoyer, has been actively exploring options to address this issue, but high-profile trades, such as one for Sandy Alcantara, have proven elusive due to Miami’s steep asking price and the Cubs’ limited prospect capital.
Triston McKenzie: A Golden Opportunity for the Cubs
The Cleveland Guardians’ decision to designate Triston McKenzie for assignment has sent shockwaves through the MLB. McKenzie, a 27-year-old right-handed pitcher, was once considered one of the brightest young arms in baseball. His 2022 season, where he recorded a 2.96 ERA over 191.1 innings, showcased his potential as a frontline starter. However, injuries and inconsistent performances in 2023 and 2024 led to his demotion to the minors and, ultimately, his DFA status in 2025.
For the Cubs, McKenzie represents a low-risk, high-reward opportunity. Because he was designated for assignment, the Cubs could potentially claim him off waivers or acquire him in a trade for minimal cost. This move aligns with the Cubs’ strategy of taking calculated risks on talented players who have yet to reach their full potential. McKenzie’s youth, experience, and upside make him an intriguing option to fill the void left by Steele.
Why McKenzie Fits the Cubs’ Needs
-
Proven Talent: Despite recent struggles, McKenzie has shown he can compete at the MLB level. His 2022 season demonstrated his ability to handle a heavy workload and dominate hitters with his fastball-curveball combination. If the Cubs’ pitching coaches, led by Tommy Hottovy, can help McKenzie regain his form, he could become a valuable asset.
-
Cost-Effective Acquisition: Unlike a blockbuster trade for a pitcher like Alcantara, acquiring McKenzie would require minimal financial or prospect capital. This allows the Cubs to preserve their farm system while addressing an immediate need.
-
Upside Potential: At just 27 years old, McKenzie is still in the prime of his career. A change of scenery and a fresh start in Chicago could help him rediscover the form that made him a top prospect. The Cubs have a history of successfully rehabilitating pitchers, as seen with Kyle Hendricks and Jake Arrieta.
-
Rotation Flexibility: If Steele returns to full health, McKenzie could slide into a middle-of-the-rotation role or even serve as a high-impact reliever. His versatility gives the Cubs options as they navigate the challenges of a long season.
Challenges and Risks with McKenzie
While McKenzie offers significant upside, there are risks associated with acquiring him. His recent performance has been inconsistent, with a 5.11 ERA in 2024 and struggles with command. Injuries have also been a concern, as he missed significant time in 2023 due to elbow and shoulder issues. The Cubs would need to carefully evaluate his medical history and ensure he can handle the rigors of a full season.
Additionally, McKenzie’s transition to a new team could take time. Adjusting to a new pitching coach, catcher, and ballpark environment may lead to growing pains. However, the Cubs’ strong clubhouse culture and experienced coaching staff could help ease this transition.
The Cubs’ Path Forward
Acquiring Triston McKenzie could be a game-changer for the Chicago Cubs as they look to solidify their rotation and make a playoff push in 2025. While he may not immediately replicate Steele’s production, his potential to become a reliable starter makes him a worthwhile investment. The Cubs’ front office must act quickly, as other teams are likely to express interest in McKenzie given his age and track record.
If the Cubs successfully claim McKenzie, they should focus on a development plan that prioritizes his health and confidence. Working closely with the team’s pitching coaches and medical staff, McKenzie could gradually rebuild his value and contribute to the Cubs’ success. In the best-case scenario, he could emerge as a key piece of the rotation alongside Steele, Imanaga, and Hendricks.
What This Means for Cubs Fans
For Cubs fans, the possibility of adding Triston McKenzie is an exciting development. The team’s pitching staff has been a source of frustration at times, but this move could signal a proactive approach to addressing those concerns. A healthy and effective McKenzie would give the Cubs the depth they need to compete in a tough division and make a deep playoff run.
Moreover, this acquisition aligns with the Cubs’ long-term vision of building a sustainable contender. By taking a chance on a young, talented pitcher like McKenzie, the Cubs are investing in their future while addressing an immediate need. Fans should keep a close eye on how this situation unfolds, as it could have significant implications for the team’s 2025 season and beyond.
Conclusion
The Chicago Cubs are at a crossroads in the 2025 season, and the potential acquisition of Triston McKenzie could be a defining moment. With Justin Steele’s availability in question, McKenzie offers a cost-effective and high-upside solution to the team’s pitching woes. While there are risks involved, the Cubs’ track record of developing pitchers and their need for rotation depth make this an opportunity worth pursuing. As the MLB landscape continues to shift, the Cubs have a chance to turn a stroke of luck into a major win for their franchise. Stay tuned as the Cubs navigate this pivotal moment in their quest for postseason glory.
