Braden Shewmake Explains Why He Loves the Yankees More Than the Royals – And Why It’s Stirring Up Controversy

Braden Shewmake’s recent candid remarks about why he prefers the New York Yankees over the Kansas City Royals have ignited a heated debate among baseball fans, sparking strong reactions and passionate discussions across social media. The versatile infielder, who was claimed off waivers by the Yankees after brief stints with the Royals and White Sox, didn’t hold back in explaining why the pinstripes have captured his heart – and why that might rub Royals fans the wrong way.

“The Yankees Believe in Me Like No One Else Has”

Shewmake, 27, has bounced around multiple teams recently, struggling to find consistent playing time and offensive production. Yet, he revealed that what sets the Yankees apart is the organization’s faith in his potential and the opportunity to grow within a winning culture.

“In New York, I feel like they really believe in me. It’s not just about filling a roster spot – it’s about being part of a team that expects to win every day. That kind of pressure and belief motivates me more than anything,” Shewmake said.

This statement contrasts sharply with his time in Kansas City, where he was designated for assignment shortly after being claimed off waivers. Royals fans, proud of their rebuilding efforts, have expressed frustration online, interpreting Shewmake’s comments as dismissive of their organization’s commitment to developing young talent.

From Royals Depth Piece to Yankees Utility Hopeful

Shewmake’s MLB journey has been a rollercoaster:

• Debuted with the Atlanta Braves in 2023, playing only two games.

• Traded to the White Sox, where he appeared in 29 games in 2024 but hit just .125.

• Claimed off waivers by the Royals, only to be designated for assignment again in early 2025.

• Quickly snapped up by the Yankees, who see his defensive versatility and speed as valuable depth.

Despite his offensive struggles, the Yankees’ front office has expressed optimism about Shewmake’s ability to contribute as a utility infielder and provide insurance across multiple positions.

Fan Reactions: Divided and Fiery

• Yankees Fans: Many are excited about Shewmake’s potential and appreciate his loyalty to the team’s winning culture. They see his comments as a refreshing dose of honesty and a sign of his commitment to the Bronx Bombers.

• Royals Supporters: Royals fans feel slighted, arguing that Shewmake’s remarks undervalue their rebuilding project and the opportunities they gave him. Some have called his comments “disrespectful” and “shortsighted.”

• Neutral Observers: Analysts note that Shewmake’s journey reflects the harsh realities of MLB roster churn and that his candidness about team environments highlights the importance of organizational culture in player development.

What’s Next for Shewmake?

Currently optioned to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, Shewmake faces an uphill battle to secure a lasting spot on the Yankees’ major league roster. His success may hinge on whether he can translate the confidence the Yankees have shown into improved offensive production.

The Bigger Debate: Loyalty vs. Opportunity

Shewmake’s comments have touched a nerve in the baseball community, raising larger questions about player loyalty and what factors truly drive athletes’ team preferences. Is it about opportunity and belief, or should players honor every chance they get, regardless of circumstances?

One thing is certain: Braden Shewmake’s declaration that he loves the Yankees more than the Royals has become a lightning rod for debate, and fans from both sides aren’t holding back.

What do you think? Is Shewmake justified in his praise of the Yankees, or should he have shown more respect to the Royals? Join the conversation and share your thoughts-because this story is far from over.