Derek Carr’s unexpected decision to retire this weekend has sent waves through the NFL community, potentially impacting the Green Bay Packers. This development brings new uncertainties regarding Aaron Rodgers’ future.

While many believed the four-time MVP was destined to join the Pittsburgh Steelers, former NFL player and analyst Roch Ohrnberger suggests Carr’s retirement could disrupt those plans. Ohrnberger states, “Rodgers NOT signing with Pittsburgh Steelers now makes much more sense. With Derek Carr’s retirement, I predict the New Orleans Saints will sign Rodgers within a week or so.”

This bold forecast adds another layer of intrigue, even though the Steelers seem like a logical destination for Rodgers. A sudden switch to the Saints might initially appear irrelevant from a Packers’ viewpoint but could disappoint fans anticipating a potential revenge game. The Packers are set to face the Steelers this season, not the Saints, leaving those excited for a Rodgers-Packers clash feeling let down.

Packers supporters are wary of Carr’s retirement triggering a last-minute change in Rodgers’ trajectory. While some fans cherish Rodgers for his contributions to the team, others are disillusioned by his uneasy departure and speculations about him joining the Minnesota Vikings. Regardless of individual feelings, a Rodgers versus Packers game captivates everyone, whether seen as a compelling encounter with a former star or a full-blown revenge match.

Ohrnberger’s perspective is valid; Rodgers’ hesitation might be due to waiting for new opportunities, such as the Saints’ sudden quarterback need. Yet, it’s reasonable to argue that Pittsburgh remains the ideal fit. The Steelers have qualified for the playoffs four times in the last five years and have bolstered their offense with players like star wide receiver DK Metcalf. That’s the hope. The prospect of a unique Rodgers-Packers game in Dublin has already been taken away by the league; losing the revenge match altogether would be a further disappointment.