Four Biggest Disappointments for the 49ers in 2024

The 2024 season was a challenging one for the San Francisco 49ers, and these four players stood out as the most disappointing:

Deebo Samuel: This pick comes as no surprise. There was much excitement about Deebo Samuel’s impressive performance in training camp and his peak physical condition, but that hype didn’t translate to success on the field. Samuel’s 2024 season was arguably the worst of his career, with an average target separation of just 3.1 yards, the lowest of his career. He struggled both as a wide receiver and a running back, managing only two carries of 10+ yards—the lowest since 2020, when he started only four games. The bright side? Samuel has a history of bouncing back after poor seasons, so optimism remains for 2025.

Ji’Ayir Brown: The biggest liability on the 49ers’ defense was Ji’Ayir Brown. Despite high expectations following a promising rookie season, Brown failed to make significant strides in 2024. His poor tackling and decision-making, apart from a standout game against the Dallas Cowboys where he recorded an interception, defined his season. Brown’s future with the team now seems uncertain.

Brock Purdy: The pressure was on Brock Purdy to build off a stellar 2023 season where he finished as an MVP finalist and performed well in the Super Bowl. Sadly, 2024 saw a significant regression. While losing some of his best weapons to injuries didn’t help, Purdy’s poor decision-making, inaccuracies, and holding onto the ball for too long were major issues. He’s not a bad player by any means, but this past season was a disappointment, making 2025 crucial for his redemption.

Kyle Shanahan: Head coach Kyle Shanahan is also under the spotlight. When a team faces such a disappointing season, the responsibility often falls on the head coach. Shanahan’s playcalling lacked identity, the team displayed a lack of discipline, and there were numerous blown leads that led to losses. The team’s struggles can be attributed to Shanahan’s approach this season, but he remains hopeful about correcting his mistakes in the upcoming offseason.