Should the Bills Trade Myles Garrett? The Answer Is Here…

As the NFL offseason heats up, rumors have begun circulating around potential trades and player movements for the Buffalo Bills, one of which has generated significant attention: should the Bills trade Myles Garrett?

The All-Pro defensive end, currently one of the top players in the league, has been linked to various teams this offseason, with some fans and analysts speculating that Buffalo could be a potential destination. But is this the right move for the Bills? Let’s break down the situation.

Who Is Myles Garrett?

Myles Garrett, drafted as the first overall pick by the Cleveland Browns in 2017, has quickly become one of the most dominant pass rushers in the NFL. With a combination of size, speed, and power, Garrett has amassed over 60 sacks and continues to be a force on the defensive line.

Garrett has the ability to disrupt offenses single-handedly, making him a nightmare for quarterbacks across the league. He was named First-Team All-Pro in 2020 and remains a centerpiece for the Browns’ defense.

Why the Bills Might Consider a Trade

Despite the impressive numbers and on-field dominance, the idea of trading for Myles Garrett may not be as far-fetched as it seems. Here are some reasons why the Buffalo Bills could consider trading for Garrett:

1. Defensive Upgrade

The Bills’ defense has been one of the top units in the NFL in recent years, but they are often criticized for lacking a true elite pass rusher. While Von Miller is a veteran leader, Garrett’s arrival would provide an instant upgrade to the pass rush, potentially giving Buffalo one of the most formidable defensive fronts in the league.

2. Championship Window

With a Super Bowl-caliber roster already in place—led by quarterback Josh Allen—the Bills are in “win-now” mode. Adding a player like Garrett could be the missing piece they need to take down the likes of the Kansas City Chiefs and other AFC powerhouses. Garrett’s ability to pressure opposing quarterbacks in critical moments could help put the Bills over the top.

3. The Trade Market Might Be Right

The Browns may be looking to reshape their roster, and if they feel Garrett could fetch a high return in a trade, they may be willing to listen to offers. If the Bills can strike a deal without giving up too much future capital, acquiring a player of Garrett’s caliber could be an absolute steal.

Why the Bills Should Think Twice About Trading for Garrett

However, there are several factors that could give Buffalo pause in pursuing a trade for Garrett:

1. High Cost

Myles Garrett is one of the highest-paid defensive players in the NFL. Trading for him would involve taking on his significant contract, which could limit the Bills’ flexibility with their salary cap. Given that Buffalo is already investing heavily in star players like Josh Allen, Tre’Davious White, and others, making room for Garrett’s salary could create financial strain.

2. Defensive Depth

While the Bills do need more pass-rushing prowess, they already have some talent on the defensive line. Players like Greg Rousseau, Boogie Basham, and A.J. Epenesa have shown potential and could be developed further. The Bills may feel their current defensive line, combined with Von Miller’s leadership, is enough to continue competing at a high level without making a massive splash move for Garrett.

3. The Long-Term Commitment

Trading for Garrett would be a long-term commitment for the Bills. While Garrett is still in his prime, his massive contract extension could impact the team’s ability to re-sign other important players in the future. For a team that has Super Bowl aspirations, giving up valuable draft picks or future assets may not be worth the risk.

4. Draft Capital and Future Planning

The Bills have been building their team through the draft, and sacrificing multiple high draft picks for Garrett might not align with their long-term strategy. The team has had success in developing young talent, and giving up potential future contributors could hinder their ability to keep their roster competitive in the future.

Conclusion: Should the Bills Trade for Myles Garrett?

After weighing the pros and cons, the answer may not be so clear-cut. While adding a player of Myles Garrett’s caliber would certainly make the Bills’ defense more dangerous, it would also require a significant financial and roster sacrifice.

Ultimately, the Buffalo Bills may be better off focusing on their existing defensive line and bolstering other areas of the team, such as their offensive line or secondary. If Garrett becomes available for the right price, the Bills should consider making a move, but they should be cautious about giving up too much of their future for a win-now acquisition.

In the end, it all comes down to whether the Bills’ front office believes that Garrett’s presence would help push them over the edge for a Super Bowl victory. For now, Buffalo fans can only wait and see how the offseason unfolds.