The Green Bay Packers are reportedly keen on retaining veteran kicker Brandon McManus in 2025, but is his future in Green Bay truly set in stone? While general manager Brian Gutekunst has expressed his desire to bring McManus back, just eight words could determine whether he returns to Lambeau Field or if the Packers explore other options[1].

**Gutekunst’s Approval: “We Would Want…McManus Back”**

Packers general manager Brian Gutekunst confirmed he’d like to bring back veteran kicker Brandon McManus in 2025 after he stabilized the position this past season[1]. Gutekunst stated, “We would. Had a good conversation with him before he left. Obviously, how he solidified that journey (at kicker) we were going on. He’s a veteran guy. The thing that was so neat about being around him was not only his confidence but also his ability to adjust, no matter where we were or what weather we had”[1]. Gutekunst added, “If we were able to get Brandon back, it would make me feel very, very good about that group”[1].

**The Eight Words That Could Change Everything**

Those eight words are: **”The Packers will explore all kicking options.”**

While Gutekunst’s comments suggest a strong interest in re-signing McManus, the Packers may still want to evaluate all available kickers before committing to him[1]. This could include:

* **Evaluating Free Agents:** Several other kickers could be available in free agency, and the Packers may want to assess their skills and cost before re-signing McManus.
* **Drafting a Kicker:** The Packers could also consider drafting a kicker in the 2025 NFL Draft.
* **Bringing in Undrafted Free Agents:** Green Bay may also look at undrafted free agent kickers.

**McManus’ 2024 Season: Stability at a Troubled Position**

McManus signed a one-year contract with the Packers on October 15 and brought much-needed stability to the kicker position[1]. During the regular season, he made 20 of 21 field goals and all 30 extra points, including two game-winning field goals and hitting all three of his attempts over 50 yards[1]. He provided consistency, converting 21 of 23 field goals[7].

**McManus Non-Commitment:**

While McManus is appreciative of the Packers giving him a chance this year, he would not comment on whether they had the upper hand in signing him in 2025[2].

**What’s Next?**

Brandon McManus’ future with the Packers hinges on several factors, including his asking price, the performance of other kickers in the league, and the Packers’ overall offseason plans[2]. While Gutekunst has expressed interest in bringing him back, the Packers may still explore other options before making a final decision[1]. If they do, those eight words could kick off a kicking competition in Green Bay.