49ers’ Dilemma: Can They Overcome Aiyuk’s Injury and Should They Chase Davante Adams?

The San Francisco 49ers are determined to address the issues that led to their disappointing 2024 season. However, one problem without a clear solution is the injury to star receiver Brandon Aiyuk, which casts uncertainty over his readiness for the 2025 season.

Aiyuk, who signed a four-year, $120 million extension last year, suffered a torn ACL, MCL, and meniscus damage during a Week 7 loss to the Kansas City Chiefs. While there have been no reports of setbacks in his recovery, the severity of the injury leaves no guarantees for his return by season kickoff.

Aiyuk is the 49ers’ premier route-runner, known for his ability to create separation at all levels. His absence last season exposed the team’s struggle to break free from coverage. Pro Football Focus’ 2024 separation percentage stats highlight this disparity: Aiyuk ranked 12th with a 65.38% separation rate, while teammates Deebo Samuel (45.22%), Ricky Pearsall (50%), George Kittle (53.33%), and Jauan Jennings (55.62%) lagged behind.

A potential solution could lie in acquiring Davante Adams, who achieved his fifth consecutive 1,000-yard season with the Las Vegas Raiders and New York Jets in 2024. Adams’ 63.78% separation rate ranks 18th, making him a valuable asset. However, his future with the Jets is uncertain. New York could save $29.8 million by releasing him post-trade from the Raiders, and there has been no communication between Adams and the Jets’ new management.

NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport reports that Adams, facing a hefty $38.2 million cap hit, might prefer a move to the West Coast. Adams grew up in East Palo Alto, close to the 49ers’ Levi’s Stadium, making San Francisco a potential fit. Adding Adams could not only serve as insurance for Aiyuk but also provide a complementary target to divert defensive attention.

Yet, with other draft priorities, receiver may not be the 49ers’ primary focus. First-round pick Pearsall showed promise, and the team boasts talent with Aiyuk, Kittle, Samuel, Jennings, and Christian McCaffrey. Adams might eventually voice concerns over target distribution, and his salary demands could strain the 49ers’ budget, especially with upcoming contract talks for Brock Purdy and George Kittle.

Still, as Aiyuk’s status remains one of the biggest unknowns for 2025, keeping an eye on Adams’ situation with the Jets could be crucial for the 49ers.