Did the 49ers Inquire About a Potential Trade for J.J. McCarthy?

San Francisco’s Quarterback Situation Remains a Mystery

The San Francisco 49ers are entering the 2024 NFL offseason with a roster that looks primed for another deep playoff run. However, one lingering question remains: Is Brock Purdy the team’s undisputed franchise quarterback? Recent speculation suggests that the 49ers may have explored potential trade options, including a possible inquiry into Minnesota Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy.

49ers’ Commitment to Brock Purdy Still Uncertain

Last month, 49ers owner Jed York publicly stated his desire to keep Purdy in San Francisco for the long term. However, what “long term” means remains up for debate. While Purdy has performed well on his rookie contract, the front office may decide to leverage the franchise tag rather than commit to a lengthy and expensive extension. This uncertainty has fueled speculation that the team could be open to alternative quarterback options.

J.J. McCarthy’s Potential and the 49ers’ Interest

McCarthy was a first-round pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, but he didn’t see action last season due to a knee injury. Despite that, he brings an impressive pedigree, having won a National Championship under Jim Harbaugh at Michigan. Additionally, McCarthy has already spent a season learning under Vikings head coach Kevin O’Connell, making him an intriguing asset for teams seeking a young quarterback with long-term upside.

NFL Network’s Tom Pelissero recently reported that the Vikings have received trade calls regarding McCarthy from multiple teams. While he did not specify which teams have shown interest, it’s not far-fetched to consider the 49ers as potential suitors. Given their history of bold quarterback moves, the front office could be keeping their options open.

What This Means for the 49ers’ Offseason Strategy

The 49ers have already made a notable quarterback move by signing Mac Jones to a two-year deal. While Jones isn’t expected to challenge Purdy for the starting job, his presence signals that the team is actively evaluating its quarterback depth. If the 49ers truly were among the teams reaching out to the Vikings about McCarthy, it would suggest that they are considering a cost-effective, high-upside alternative to Purdy.

Additionally, this raises another question: If Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders were to fall to the 49ers in the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft, would they consider drafting him? The team’s willingness to explore quarterback options indicates that nothing is off the table until Purdy’s contract situation is fully resolved.

Final Thoughts: Are the 49ers Preparing for a Major Move?

For now, the Vikings appear unwilling to part ways with McCarthy, and Purdy remains the starter in San Francisco. However, until Purdy signs a long-term extension, the possibility of the 49ers making a bold quarterback move remains in play. Whether it’s through a trade, free agency, or the draft, San Francisco’s front office seems committed to keeping their options open. The offseason is just beginning, and with the 49ers’ track record, surprises could still be in store.