Should the 49ers Trade Brandon Aiyuk to Save Cash?

The Financial Dilemma Facing San Francisco

The San Francisco 49ers are in a tricky financial situation heading into the offseason. When general manager John Lynch was asked at the NFL Combine about the possibility of trading wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk, he acknowledged that the team was facing tighter financial constraints than usual. Shortly after, the team made a significant move by trading Deebo Samuel to the Washington Commanders, saving a crucial $15.4 million in the process.

Aiyuk’s Expensive Contract and Injury Concerns

While moving Samuel provided some relief, Aiyuk’s contract presents an even greater financial challenge. The star wide receiver is due a massive $22.855 million option bonus on April 1, and with the team already working within budgetary constraints, trading him could be the most straightforward way to create cap space.

However, Aiyuk’s situation is complicated by his recent injury. He suffered devastating ACL, MCL, and meniscus tears last season, leaving his future uncertain. The 49ers must evaluate whether he can fully recover his speed, agility, and explosiveness—the very qualities that made him such a dynamic playmaker. If there are doubts about his long-term health, moving his contract before it becomes a burden may be the wisest move.

Trade Value: What Could the 49ers Get in Return?

The market for Aiyuk isn’t as strong as it once was. Despite being a top-tier receiver, his injury and high contract make him a tough sell. When the 49ers traded Samuel, they received just a fifth-round pick in return. Given Aiyuk’s current condition and financial implications, they might only fetch a fourth-round pick at best. The question remains: is that a worthwhile return for a player who, when healthy, is a difference-maker?

Should the 49ers Make the Move?

The decision ultimately comes down to risk assessment. If the organization believes Aiyuk won’t fully recover, it would be prudent to move him now while they can still get some value in return. Letting his contract become an unmovable liability could haunt the franchise in the coming years.

On the other hand, if there’s confidence in his rehabilitation and future performance, trading him simply to save money could be a regrettable decision. A fully healthy Aiyuk could remain a cornerstone of the 49ers’ offense for years to come.

With the clock ticking toward his contract deadline, the 49ers have a critical choice to make. Will they prioritize financial flexibility, or will they bet on Aiyuk’s ability to return to form? The answer could shape the team’s future for seasons to come.