Brock Purdy and the 49ers: A Future Defined by Faith and Potential

The Franchise’s Commitment to Purdy
Despite a disappointing 6-11 season, the San Francisco 49ers remain steadfast in their belief that Brock Purdy is the future of their franchise at quarterback. Head coach Kyle Shanahan made this clear in the team’s end-of-season press conference, stating, “Brock is the leader of our team. I’ve loved these three years with Brock, and I plan on being with him here as long as I’m here.”

This unwavering support highlights the organization’s trust in Purdy, even as questions about his long-term value loom following a season that fell short of expectations.

A Season of Challenges
Purdy’s 2024 campaign was a departure from his electrifying 2023 performance. Injuries to key offensive players and a less consistent supporting cast exposed some vulnerabilities. Yet, it’s important to note that Purdy wasn’t the primary reason the 49ers missed the playoffs for the first time since 2020. His resilience and flashes of brilliance offer a strong case for continued investment.

The Jared Goff Comparison
Purdy’s future contract negotiations will inevitably draw comparisons to quarterbacks like Jared Goff. Goff’s four-year, $212 million extension in Detroit, which included a record-setting $73 million signing bonus, rewarded his role in leading the Lions to the brink of a Super Bowl appearance.

However, Goff’s postseason struggles, particularly in the divisional round against the Washington Commanders, have reignited debates about his limitations. Goff’s three-interception performance, including a critical pick-six, underscored his inability to consistently perform under pressure.

In contrast, Purdy’s ability to rise to the occasion in high-pressure moments, such as the 49ers’ dramatic 17-point comeback against Detroit in 2023, paints a different picture of his potential.

Mobility: A Defining Difference
One key factor that sets Purdy apart from quarterbacks like Goff is his mobility. While Goff is capable of executing plays outside the pocket, his effectiveness when the structure of the offense breaks down is questionable. This limitation became glaringly evident during Detroit’s playoff exit, as Washington’s relentless pass rush disrupted Goff’s rhythm.

Purdy, on the other hand, has demonstrated an innate ability to extend plays. His scramble rate of 8.3% in 2024, comparable to dynamic quarterback Lamar Jackson, reflects his knack for creating opportunities when under pressure. Purdy ranked eighth in rushing Expected Points Added (EPA) among quarterbacks with at least 100 plays, while Goff posted a negative EPA of -3.1 as a rusher.

This athletic advantage provides Purdy with additional avenues to overcome defensive pressure, adding a crucial dimension to the 49ers’ offense that Goff lacks.

Purdy’s Potential in the Modern NFL
The modern NFL increasingly values quarterbacks who can adapt and excel outside the confines of structured play. Purdy’s ability to execute second-reaction plays—those moments of brilliance when a quarterback improvises under duress—positions him as a valuable asset in today’s game.

While Goff and Purdy may share similarities in their physical throwing abilities, their overall athletic profiles couldn’t be more different. Purdy’s mobility and agility give him the edge in situations where creativity and quick decision-making are essential.

Looking Ahead: A Contract Worth the Investment
Statistically, Purdy wasn’t flawless under pressure in 2024, with a passer rating of 78.6 and an equal number of big-time throws and turnover-worthy plays. However, his capacity to mitigate the rush and make plays with his legs makes him a more dynamic option compared to Goff.

The 49ers’ faith in Purdy appears well-founded. As negotiations for a top-tier quarterback contract loom, Purdy’s versatility and playmaking ability provide compelling reasons for the team to confidently meet his demands.

In the evolving landscape of NFL quarterbacking, Brock Purdy represents not just the 49ers’ present but also their future—a future defined by promise, adaptability, and the unwavering support of an organization ready to build around its young leader.