“We expect fully that Aiyuk will be a part of us moving forward,” 49ers GM John Lynch declared last week, his tone as steady as a Joe Montana two-minute drill. But in the NFL, expectations crumble faster than a rookie QB’s pocket presence. While Lynch was busy penciling Brandon Aiyuk into San Francisco’s 2025 plans, head coach Kyle Shanahan was reportedly scribbling exit strategies in the margins.

Enter the chaos: Aiyuk, the $120M receiver with 4,305 career yards and a freshly torn ACL, now finds himself trapped in a game of contractual limbo—and Shanahan’s playbook might include a shocking twist. Brock Purdy, the $1M miracle QB, could soon be tossing dimes to… Keenan Allen? Is this the same Allen who got ghosted by Chicago so hard they reassigned his jersey number faster than you can say “Bear Market”? Buckle up, Faithful. This isn’t just a roster shuffle. It’s a full-blown identity crisis.

Let’s rewind. Aiyuk—the human highlight reel who defied gravity for that NFC Championship catch—isn’t just rehabbing a knee. He’s rehabbing his future. After inking a four-year, $120M extension last August, the 27-year-old managed just 25 catches for 374 yards before his 2024 season ended in October.

via Getty

Now? His trade value’s colder than a Candlestick Park bleacher seat. “He’s working really hard,” Lynch insisted, but Shanahan’s silence screams louder. ESPN’s Adam Schefter hinted at a mid-season return, but FOX Sports’ Ralph Vacchiano isn’t buying the sunshine: “The 49ers act more like a rebuilding team than one trying to contend.” Translation: Aiyuk’s $29M guaranteed might as well be Monopoly money in Santa Clara’s cap-strapped world.

Steve Smith Sr. Gives Final Verdict on Texas WR’s Future as 21-YO Makes Heads Turn With Cowboys’ Jerry Jones Move

Trading him now? That’d trigger a $38M dead cap hit—financial seppuku. But Shanahan, the architect who turned Matt Breida into a 1,000-yard back, thrives on chaos. “They’re either competing or they’re not,” he’d say. And comfort died the day Deebo Samuel got shipped to Washington.

Meanwhile, Aiyuk’s camp sweats. His $76M guaranteed once felt like dynasty cement. Now? It’s a ticking clock. With Purdy’s mega-deal looming—“the largest in franchise history,” per Lynch—Shanahan’s eyeing the reset button. And if that means dangling Aiyuk for draft capital? Well, Succession’s Logan Roy put it best: “You’re not serious people.”

Purdy & Shanahan’s outcast: Keenan Allen’s redemption arc

While Aiyuk’s future flickers, Shanahan’s already scripting a new subplot: Purdy + Allen = offensive alchemy. Let’s set the scene. Allen, the Chargers’ all-time receptions leader (974 catches, 11,274 yards), got Cast Away by Chicago without so much as a “thanks for the Pro Bowls.” The Bears handed his No. 13 to Maurice Alexander—a move as subtle as a pick-six in overtime. Cue the NFL rumor mill: “Keenan Allen is not expected to return to the Bears. The Chargers and 49ers could be possible destinations.”

Shanahan’s ears perked up. Allen, even at 33, is a route-running savant. Despite catching passes from a rookie QB in Chicago’s dumpster-fire offense, he racked up 744 yards and 7 TDs in 2024. “Run it back turbo,” former Chargers teammate Mike Williams posted on IG, tagging Allen. Even Jim Harbaugh, tighter-lipped than a goal-line formation, cracked: “Make $23M a year and play in Chicago? Who’s got it better?”

For Shanahan, this isn’t nostalgia. It’s a necessity. With Aiyuk’s health shaky and Deebo gone, Allen’s a Swiss Army knife. Remember 2019? Emmanuel Sanders arrived mid-season, and Purdy’s predecessor, Jimmy G, suddenly looked MVP-caliber. Allen’s crisp curls and slants could unlock Purdy’s deep-ball potential—assuming the 49ers ever pay the guy. “Hold that thought, Brock,” Kyle Shanahan whispers, because Allen isn’t a luxury. He’s the Infinity Stone Kyle needs to snap his Super Bowl drought.