“Buffalo Bills: The Herd Mentality That Could Change Everything”

The Buffalo Bills fanbase, known for its loud, passionate, and fiercely loyal supporters, has been riding high with some incredible performances and crucial decisions. However, as we dive into this week’s Herd Mentality episode, the discussion is about more than just wins and losses—it’s about the future, and more specifically, which key players will continue to shine in Buffalo’s future plans.

On today’s show, Joe Marino, the voice behind The Locked On Bills podcast, goes deep into some of the most debated topics in the Bills’ community. From contract extensions to player versatility, let’s break down how these moves might shape the team and its dynasty aspirations.

The Big Decisions Ahead: Extensions and Contracts

The Bills’ offseason is a crucial time. The team’s roster is full of young stars like James Cook, Terrell Bernard, Greg Rousseau, and others, all up for contract extensions. But here’s the kicker: Not all of them are expiring contracts. James Cook, Bernard, and Greg Rousseau have time left on their deals until 2025, while only Damar Hamlin’s contract will expire soon. So, is there urgency to get extensions done, or can the Bills afford to be patient?

The big questions loom over James Cook. At a projected $10.2 million annual value, is he worth it? Cook has been versatile, contributing to the offense but only playing about 45% of the snaps, compared to workhorse backs like Saquon Barkley. Should the Bills bet big on Cook’s potential or settle for a more modest deal that reflects his role as a secondary option?

On the other side, the bills have Terrell Bernard at a modest $6.7 million—less than expected for a rising star who’s been an anchor for the defense. How does his projected value compare to others in his position, like Logan Wilson or Jermaine Pratt?

Then there’s Greg Rousseau, potentially looking at a $24.9 million extension, but here’s the deal: Rousseau’s fifth-year option cap hit for 2025 is already set at over $13 million, so the extension might allow the team to adjust that number and free up some cap space.

Khalil Shakir: Slot or Superstar?
One player causing a stir in Buffalo is Khalil Shakir. The question is—does his lack of versatility as a slot-only player hurt his market value, especially when compared to players who can line up both inside and outside? Shakir played about 75% of his snaps in the slot, raising concerns about whether his production is easy to replace. Can the Bills afford to keep him at a premium rate if the offense has other slot options, or is Shakir a player worth betting on as a key contributor to their passing game?

It’s not just about Shakir’s ability to get open; it’s about how the offense can utilize him moving forward. As Dan asks in a listener question, does the lack of versatility drive up opportunity cost for other players who could take his snaps—like Cole Beasley or even rookie talents?

The Bottom Line: Who’s Worth The Money?
As we look toward the Bills’ future, these contract decisions will shape the team’s success for years to come. Can the team afford to lock down these key players when they are all vying for big bucks?

For Buffalo fans, this is where the real conversation begins. Which players are worth the financial gamble? Do the Bills go all-in on their future stars like Rousseau, Bernard, or Benford? Or do they take a more conservative approach, spreading out the contracts and keeping cap space flexible for a playoff push?

Your Turn: What Do You Think?
Yankees fans, you’ve weighed in. Bills Mafia, now it’s your turn! Who would you extend, and who should be sent packing? Does Shakir’s lack of versatility make him expendable? Or do you think he can elevate his game next season? Drop your comments below, share this with your fellow Bills fans, and let’s get this conversation trending!

Don’t forget to subscribe, like, and turn on notifications so you’re always in the know for the latest on your Buffalo Bills.