Lions GM Brad Holmes Delivers Unfortunate News on Za’Darius Smith’s Potential Return

April 20, 2025 – Detroit Lions fans hoping for a reunion with former defensive end Za’Darius Smith received disappointing news this week. During a pre-draft media session on April 17, Lions general manager Brad Holmes addressed questions about Smith, a fan favorite who was traded to the team at the 2024 trade deadline. Holmes’ comments dashed hopes of Smith returning to the Lions’ roster, signaling that the team is moving forward without the veteran pass rusher. This development has sparked widespread discussion among fans and analysts, as the Lions prepare for the 2025 NFL Draft. Below, we explore the details of Holmes’ statement, Smith’s impact on the Lions, and what this means for the team’s future.

The News: Holmes’ Comments on Za’Darius Smith

During his annual pre-draft press conference, Brad Holmes was asked about Za’Darius Smith, who remains a free agent after being released by the Lions last month due to salary cap constraints. Smith, who was spotted at a Detroit Pistons game recently, had fueled speculation about a possible return to the Motor City. However, Holmes was clear in his response, stating that there was “nothing new to report” regarding Smith and a potential reunion with the Lions. He emphasized the team’s focus on the upcoming draft and existing roster, effectively closing the door on immediate plans to re-sign the 32-year-old defensive end.

This news came as a blow to fans who had grown fond of Smith during his brief but impactful stint with the Lions in 2024. Posts on X echoed this sentiment, with some fans expressing frustration over the lack of progress in negotiations, while others acknowledged the team’s salary cap challenges. Holmes’ pragmatic approach underscores his reputation as a disciplined general manager, prioritizing long-term roster-building over short-term fan appeasement.

Za’Darius Smith’s Time with the Lions

Za’Darius Smith joined the Lions midseason in 2024 via a trade with the Cleveland Browns, a move prompted by a wave of injuries to Detroit’s defensive line, including star edge rusher Aidan Hutchinson. Smith quickly proved his worth, recording nine sacks in just 10 games and providing much-needed stability to a depleted unit. His ability to disrupt opposing offenses, combined with his veteran leadership, made him an instant hit among teammates and fans alike.

Off the field, Smith embraced Detroit’s culture, forming a high-profile relationship with rapper Kash Doll and engaging with the local community. His presence at a Pistons game in early April 2025 reignited hopes that he might re-sign with the Lions, especially given his expressed fondness for the city. However, the Lions’ decision to release Smith last month was driven by financial considerations, as his $12.2 million cap hit for 2025 was deemed unsustainable given the team’s need to extend contracts for young stars like Hutchinson, Jameson Williams, and Kerby Joseph.

Smith’s release was a tough pill to swallow for fans, who saw him as a key piece of the Lions’ 15-win 2024 campaign, which ended in a heartbreaking divisional round loss to the Washington Commanders. His departure highlighted the harsh realities of the NFL salary cap, where even beloved players can become casualties of financial strategy.

Why the Lions Are Moving On

Brad Holmes’ decision to distance the Lions from a potential Smith reunion reflects his broader philosophy of roster management. Since taking over as GM in 2021, Holmes has built a reputation as one of the NFL’s elite executives, earning praise for his draft success and disciplined approach to free agency. Former NFL GM Mike Tannenbaum recently placed Holmes in an “elite category” for his ability to draft impact players like Penei Sewell, Amon-Ra St. Brown, and Jahmyr Gibbs.

Holmes has prioritized re-signing homegrown talent and maintaining cap flexibility for future extensions. In 2025, the Lions have already extended players like Levi Onwuzurike, Derrick Barnes, and Tim Patrick, while planning for costly deals for Hutchinson and Williams. With only $5.3 million in projected cap space for 2026, re-signing Smith would require significant financial maneuvering.

Additionally, Holmes expressed confidence in the Lions’ current pass-rushing unit, particularly with Hutchinson expected to return fully healthy from his 2024 leg injury. During the NFL owners meetings, Holmes described Hutchinson as a “no-concern” recovery case, signaling that the team views him as the cornerstone of their defensive front. The Lions also have depth with players like Marcus Davenport and Alim McNeill, reducing the urgency to bring back Smith.

Holmes’ draft strategy further explains the decision. Known for selecting the best player available rather than chasing positional needs, Holmes is likely eyeing the 2025 draft to add a young edge rusher or versatile defender. Analysts like Mike Tannenbaum have projected the Lions to target a safety like Georgia’s Malaki Starks, but Holmes’ history of bold draft-day trades suggests he could surprise with an unexpected pick.

What’s Next for Za’Darius Smith?

For Smith, the Lions’ decision leaves him in limbo as the 2025 NFL Draft approaches. At 32, he remains a productive player, with 69 career sacks across nine seasons with the Baltimore Ravens, Green Bay Packers, Minnesota Vikings, Cleveland Browns, and Lions. His performance in Detroit last year proved he can still be a difference-maker, making him an attractive option for teams needing pass-rush help.

However, the longer Smith remains unsigned, the more his market may soften, as teams finalize their rosters post-draft. Some speculate that the Lions could revisit negotiations later in the offseason, similar to their approach with C.J. Gardner-Johnson in 2023, but Holmes’ comments suggest this is unlikely unless Smith’s asking price drops significantly.

Smith’s personal ties to Detroit, including his relationship with Kash Doll, may keep him in the city’s orbit, but his next NFL destination remains uncertain. Teams like the Philadelphia Eagles, New York Jets (coached by former Lions DC Aaron Glenn), or other playoff contenders could emerge as suitors, offering Smith a chance to chase a Super Bowl ring.

Fan Reaction and the Bigger Picture

The news about Smith has stirred mixed emotions among Lions fans. On X, some expressed disappointment, with one user writing, “Za’Darius was a beast for us—wish we could keep him!” Others supported Holmes’ decision, citing the need to invest in younger players. This divide reflects the challenge of balancing emotional attachment to players with the business side of the NFL.

For the Lions, the focus now shifts to the 2025 draft, where Holmes and head coach Dan Campbell aim to build on their recent success. The team’s 15-win season in 2024 raised expectations, and despite coaching staff changes— including the departures of offensive coordinator Ben Johnson to the Chicago Bears and defensive coordinator Aaron Glenn to the New York Jets—Detroit remains a Super Bowl contender.

Holmes’ track record suggests he will make calculated moves to strengthen the roster, whether through the draft or strategic free-agent signings. While Za’Darius Smith’s chapter with the Lions appears to be over, his contributions in 2024 will be remembered as part of the team’s resurgence.

Conclusion

Brad Holmes’ announcement that Za’Darius Smith is unlikely to return to the Detroit Lions marks the end of a brief but memorable era. Smith’s impact on and off the field endeared him to fans, but the realities of the salary cap and the Lions’ long-term vision have taken precedence. As Detroit prepares for the 2025 NFL Draft, Holmes’ disciplined approach and draft prowess will be key to sustaining the team’s momentum. For Smith, the search for his next NFL home continues, leaving fans hopeful that he finds a fitting destination.