Dansby Swanson’s Alarming Slump with the Chicago Cubs: Can the $177M Star Overcome His Offensive Woes and Silence the Doubters?

Dansby Swanson, the Chicago Cubs’ $177 million shortstop, is under intense scrutiny in the 2025 season as his offensive struggles continue to cast a shadow over his elite defensive prowess. Signed to a seven-year contract in 2022, Swanson was expected to be a cornerstone for the Cubs’ postseason aspirations. However, with a batting average of .181, a .577 OPS, and a troubling 50% strikeout rate in high-leverage situations as of April 28, 2025, fans and analysts are questioning whether he can justify his massive deal. This article dives into Swanson’s challenges, the Cubs’ reliance on him, and whether the 31-year-old star can turn things around.

A Disappointing Offensive Output

Swanson’s 2025 season has been defined by offensive inconsistency. Despite hitting 4 home runs and driving in 15 RBIs, his .181 batting average and .577 OPS are far below expectations for a player of his caliber. His situational hitting is particularly concerning, with a .176 average with runners on base and a dismal .143 average with runners in scoring position. These numbers highlight a player struggling to deliver in clutch moments, a stark contrast to his reputation as a reliable performer during his Atlanta Braves tenure.

Swanson’s struggles aren’t entirely new. Lingering injuries in 2024 prompted core surgery in October of that year, intended to restore his physical form. While he’s shown flashes of brilliance—occasionally delivering clutch hits—his overall production hasn’t rebounded as hoped. For a Cubs team aiming to compete in the NL Central, Swanson’s inability to provide consistent offense at shortstop is a growing concern.

Defensive Excellence Keeps Him in the Lineup

Despite his offensive woes, Swanson remains a defensive stalwart. His Gold Glove-caliber play at shortstop, characterized by exceptional range and a strong arm, continues to anchor the Cubs’ infield. Advanced metrics like Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) and Ultimate Zone Rating (UZR) consistently rank him among the league’s best, making him indispensable even during his slump. The Cubs’ lack of viable alternatives at shortstop further cements his place in the lineup, as prospects like Matt Shaw are still developing and external options are limited.

However, defense alone can’t justify a $177 million contract. Fans expect offensive contributions from a player commanding such a salary, and Swanson’s current performance has fueled skepticism about his long-term value to the team.

Can Swanson Turn It Around?

The question on every Cubs fan’s mind is whether Swanson can rediscover his offensive form. His track record offers hope: in 2022 with the Braves, he hit .277 with 25 home runs and 96 RBIs, earning All-Star honors. That version of Swanson showcased a disciplined approach at the plate and the ability to hit for both power and average. Recapturing that form will require adjustments, including better pitch selection and reducing his strikeout rate in high-pressure situations.

The Cubs’ coaching staff is reportedly working with Swanson to refine his swing mechanics and mental approach. Offseason surgery addressed physical limitations, but mental fatigue from a grueling season may also be a factor. With five years left on his contract, the Cubs are banking on Swanson’s work ethic and veteran leadership to spark a turnaround.

The Road Ahead for Swanson and the Cubs

For now, the Cubs have little choice but to stick with Swanson, given his defensive value and the lack of better options. Patience is wearing thin, but a strong second half could silence doubters and reaffirm his status as a franchise cornerstone. If Swanson can regain his offensive edge, the Cubs’ infield could become a strength, propelling them toward postseason contention.

Cubs fans are holding their breath, hoping the $177 million star can overcome his slump and deliver the all-around performance they expected. Only time will tell if Swanson can rise to the challenge.