The Boston Red Sox’s 2025 season seems to be entangled in turmoil and injuries. Initially, there was upheaval at third base, and now the team is facing issues at first base. Just when the Red Sox thought their lineup was set, fate intervened. Star first baseman Triston Casas suffered a ruptured patellar tendon in his knee, ruling him out for the entire season.

This injury left a significant void in both the infield and the batting lineup. The pressing issue now is finding someone to fill his shoes. This is Casas’ second significant injury, following a broken rib in 2024 that kept him out for four months. His absence has left the team with a challenge they have yet to overcome. Adding to the internal chaos, there’s discord in the dugout. Rafael Devers, currently serving as designated hitter, was asked to assume the first base role.

He refused, citing his recent move from third base to DH. Consequently, team owner John Henry and key officials traveled to Kansas City to address the escalating tensions. The situation is undoubtedly challenging for the Red Sox, but perhaps there’s a way out. The team is now exploring external options for first base, having exhausted internal alternatives. Marianna Moreno from FanSided suggests a potential trade with the San Diego Padres for a versatile infielder with a reliable bat. Luis Arraez, who has amassed 200 hits in the past two seasons, might be the ideal candidate.

However, there are conditions to consider. Are the Red Sox prepared to part with young talent to secure him? Acquiring such a player may require sacrificing promising minor league players. Names like catcher/first baseman Nathan Hickey, pitcher Cooper Criswell, and outfield prospect Miguel Bleis are being discussed as potential trade assets. This decision would weigh immediate needs against future prospects, making it a critical choice.

Regarding Devers, his unwillingness to change positions has strained his relationship with management and raised questions about his commitment to the team’s success. He has faced similar requests in the past. Devers remarked on the situation, saying, “I know I’m a ballplayer, but they can’t expect me to play every position. In spring training, they told me to put away my glove.” He further asserted, “I wasn’t going to play anywhere other than DH. I don’t think it would be appropriate for them to ask me to switch positions now.” Devers is firm in his stance.

Does this mean the Red Sox will pursue the $14 million Padres player? With Devers unwilling to move from his DH role, the Red Sox are scrambling to address the first base dilemma—an issue compounded by injuries and limited internal options. The Red Sox’s first base struggles have intensified amid injuries and internal disputes this season. Romy Gonzalez stepped in after Casas’ season-ending injury on May 2. Over 17 games, Gonzalez batted .308 with a .785 OPS, performing admirably. However, his recent 10-day stint on the injured list due to a left quad contusion has further constrained the team’s infield options.

The Red Sox have promoted infielder Nick Sogard from Triple-A Worcester after Gonzalez’s injury. Sogard, who hit .273 in 31 games for Boston during the 2024 season, played his first game of the year on Saturday against the Kansas City Royals, where he contributed a hit and a run in a 10-1 triumph. Manager Alex Cora indicated that Sogard would be sharing responsibilities at first base with Abraham Toro, stating, “We’ll rotate him and Toro… They will be sharing the position over the next week or so.” The Red Sox are precariously balancing the need to remain competitive in the American League East while dealing with injuries and internal issues. The success of the team for the remainder of the season will hinge on their ability to adjust and find effective strategies.