As the Dallas Cowboys approach another offseason, questions about the long-term viability of quarterback Dak Prescott have resurfaced. While Prescott has been a cornerstone of the Cowboys’ offense since being drafted in 2016, his recent performances and the team’s struggles in the postseason have sparked debate: should the Cowboys consider drafting a quarterback in the first round as a potential replacement?

The Case for Drafting a Quarterback

Prescott’s tenure in Dallas has been marked by both success and inconsistency. Though he boasts impressive career stats and has led the team to multiple playoff appearances, his inability to propel the Cowboys deep into the postseason remains a sticking point. At 31, Prescott is in his prime, but injuries and rising expectations have cast a shadow over his future as the team’s franchise quarterback.

Drafting a first-round quarterback offers the Cowboys a chance to reset their salary cap situation. Prescott’s contract is one of the most expensive in the league, and finding a young, affordable option under a rookie deal could free up resources to bolster other areas of the roster. Additionally, securing a talented prospect now allows the Cowboys to groom their next signal-caller without rushing the transition.

The 2024 NFL Draft is expected to feature several promising quarterbacks, providing the Cowboys with options should they choose to invest in the position. A move like this could signal a shift in strategy, much like the Kansas City Chiefs drafting Patrick Mahomes while Alex Smith was still performing well.

The Case Against Moving On from Prescott

Despite the criticism, Prescott remains one of the most reliable quarterbacks in the league. He has shown resilience, leadership, and the ability to bounce back from adversity, including his devastating ankle injury in 2020. Prescott’s deep understanding of the Cowboys’ offense and his rapport with key players like CeeDee Lamb and Tony Pollard are assets that a rookie quarterback may take years to replicate.td

Moreover, the Cowboys’ issues extend beyond the quarterback position. The offensive line has struggled with injuries, and the defense, while improved, still needs consistency. Drafting a quarterback in the first round might not address the team’s more pressing needs and could risk wasting valuable draft capital on a position that isn’t the root of the problem.

There’s also the matter of optics. Prescott is a fan favorite and a respected leader in the locker room. Moving on from him too soon could create division among fans and players, especially if the rookie struggles to fill Prescott’s shoes.

A Balanced Approach

The Cowboys could adopt a middle-ground strategy, using a mid- or late-round pick on a developmental quarterback rather than investing their first-round selection. This approach allows them to prepare for the future without undermining Prescott in the short term. A solid backup quarterback who can be groomed over time might be the prudent choice, particularly given the unpredictability of rookie quarterbacks.td

Ultimately, the decision hinges on how the Cowboys’ front office evaluates Prescott’s trajectory and the quarterback talent in the upcoming draft. If they see an opportunity to secure a game-changing prospect, the bold move could pay dividends. However, abandoning Prescott prematurely could set the team back in its pursuit of a championship.

As the Cowboys gear up for the draft, one thing is clear: the quarterback debate will continue to dominate the headlines, keeping fans and analysts alike on the edge of their seats.