The Minnesota Vikings wrapped up their 2024 season with a strong 14-3 record, though Week 18 didn’t quite play out in their favor. What stands out is how they achieved this with Sam Darnold leading the charge at quarterback. Looking forward to 2025, a pivotal decision looms for the Vikings regarding their quarterback lineup.

When the Vikings snagged JJ McCarthy in the 2024 NFL Draft, the projection was clear—he was seen as the future of their franchise. However, fate had other plans; a torn meniscus sidelined McCarthy for his entire rookie season, paving the way for Darnold to step up.

And step up he did. Darnold has embraced the starting role, earning respect in the locker room, delivering MVP-caliber performances, and bringing valuable experience to the table.

Given this dynamic, Minnesota would be wise to consider retaining him as their starting QB.

But what about McCarthy? Despite his absence this season, his potential hasn’t waned.

With a 2025 draft class lacking quarterback depth, the Vikings could capitalize on this by trading McCarthy for significant assets. All eyes are on the Cleveland Browns, who may be the perfect trade partner.

Recent news revealed a setback for Deshaun Watson, who was expected to reassume the starting quarterback role for the Browns in 2025 after renegotiating his contract. Unfortunately, a snag in his ACL recovery might sideline him for the upcoming season. This leaves Cleveland scrambling for answers at quarterback, opening the door for a trade for McCarthy.

The connections between the Vikings and Browns run deep, courtesy of Kwesi Adofo-Mensah, Minnesota’s general manager, who previously cut his teeth in the Browns’ organization. McCarthy could be just what the Browns need—a young, agile player with promising upside to rejuvenate their quarterback situation.

Before his injury, McCarthy showcased his skills in a preseason outing, racking up 188 yards and two touchdowns, completing 11 of 18 passes with only one interception. His accuracy and knack for making plays on the run make him an enticing prospect for Cleveland’s future ambitions.

In the swirling world of NFL trades and team dynamics, decisions like these can pivot an entire franchise’s trajectory. As the offseason unfolds, the Vikings must weigh their options carefully, keeping an eye on both the present needs and future possibilities.