Eagles News: Booger McFarland Shuts Down Tush Push Critics With Bold 10-Word Statement

In the high-stakes world of NFL football, few tactics have generated as much controversy—and success—as the Philadelphia Eagles’ infamous “Tush Push.” While the play continues to dominate short-yardage situations, its effectiveness has drawn growing frustration from rival teams and analysts. But former NFL defensive lineman and current ESPN analyst Booger McFarland isn’t having any of it. In just ten words, McFarland delivered a scathing rebuke to critics of the play:
“They’re scared because they can’t stop it. Period.”

What Is the “Tush Push”?

Also known as the “Brotherly Shove,” the “Tush Push” is a short-yardage quarterback sneak popularized by the Eagles and executed almost to perfection. When the team needs just a yard or two, quarterback Jalen Hurts lines up under center, and after the snap, his offensive linemen and backfield teammates literally push him forward from behind to gain the first down or touchdown.

Though legal under current NFL rules, the play has stirred debate for allegedly giving the Eagles an “unfair advantage” in short-yardage situations. Yet no rule prevents players from pushing the ball carrier—a change that came in 2006. Still, many teams can’t replicate its success.

McFarland Speaks Out

Booger McFarland didn’t mince words when asked about the controversy on a recent ESPN broadcast. With unmistakable clarity and a touch of fire, he responded:
“They’re scared because they can’t stop it. Period.”

This powerful statement highlights what many believe is the root of the backlash: envy and frustration. Opponents aren’t upset because the play is inherently flawed or dangerous—they’re upset because it works, and they haven’t figured out how to stop it.

Eagles’ Unmatched Efficiency

The numbers don’t lie. In the 2023 season, the Eagles converted the “Tush Push” at an extraordinary rate—reportedly over 90% success on short-yardage attempts. Head coach Nick Sirianni has said the team will continue to use the play until the league says otherwise.

Far from being a “gimmick,” the Eagles’ execution of the “Tush Push” requires impeccable timing, strength, and coordination. It’s a physical battle of wills that Philadelphia continues to win, thanks in large part to their elite offensive line and Hurts’ power as a runner.

Critics Want It Banned

Several rival coaches and players have publicly lobbied for the NFL to review—or even outlaw—the “Tush Push.” Some claim it removes the skill element from the game, calling it “rugby-style” or “too mechanical.” Teams like the New York Giants and San Francisco 49ers have struggled to stop it and have voiced their concerns.

There’s also fear that the play could increase injury risk, though data does not yet support that claim. Still, the rising criticism has prompted league discussions about whether the play should be reevaluated.

Booger Isn’t Alone

McFarland isn’t the only analyst standing by the Eagles. Many argue that rather than trying to get the play banned, opposing teams should adapt and improve their defensive schemes.

NFL veteran and analyst Marcus Spears echoed similar thoughts on X (formerly Twitter):
“It’s legal. It’s effective. And y’all mad because you can’t do it. Simple.”

Others believe that if a team can innovate within the rules and succeed, it should be celebrated—not punished.

Eagles Fans Clap Back

Philadelphia fans have predictably rallied behind Booger’s statement. On social media, fans flooded comment sections with support, calling McFarland a “real one” and praising his no-nonsense defense of their team.

One fan tweeted: “If Belichick came up with the Tush Push, they’d call him a genius.”
Another posted: “Don’t blame the Eagles for being stronger, smarter, and more united.”

The Bottom Line

Booger McFarland’s 10-word statement cuts to the heart of the matter. The “Tush Push” isn’t a dirty trick—it’s a display of superior teamwork, strength, and execution. The teams that can’t stop it aren’t victims of unfair play; they’re victims of their own shortcomings.

Until the NFL changes the rules—and there’s no sign it will anytime soon—the Eagles will keep pushing forward, literally and figuratively. And as long as they do, expect McFarland and Philly fans to keep shutting down the haters with the simplest argument of all:

“They’re scared. Because they can’t stop it. Period.”