Former NFL receiver suggests the Bills should trade A.J. Epenesa to the Browns for Myles Garrett. G

nytimes.com

A former NFL receiver has suggested the Buffalo Bills should trade A.J. Epenesa to the Cleveland Browns for Myles Garrett, a proposal that’s sparking debate among fans and analysts alike. Is Garrett worth sacrificing a promising young player like Epenesa, or should the Bills stand pat and trust their current roster?

**The Trade Proposal**

The proposed trade involves the Buffalo Bills sending A.J. Epenesa to the Cleveland Browns in exchange for Myles Garrett[1]. This idea has been floated as a potential solution to address the Bills’ need for an elite pass rusher[7].

**What the Bills Would Have to Give Up**

wisportsheroics.com

The *Athletic* suggests the Bills may need to include two years of first round picks, a better Day 2 pick swap, a better Day 3 pick swap, a replacement defensive end in AJ Epenesa and Kaiir Elam to acquire Garrett[2]. Another proposal includes the Bills getting Garrett, a 2025 third-round pick (No. 94, via Buffalo) and a 2025 sixth-round pick (via Minnesota) in exchange for Epenesa and Elam[8].

**The Case for Garrett**

si.com

* **Elite Talent:** Garrett is considered an elite, generational edge rusher[4]. In 2024, Garrett had 14 sacks, 47 tackles, 22 tackles for loss, and 28 QB hits[2][3].
* **Super Bowl Contender:** Acquiring Garrett would signal the Bills are serious about competing for a Super Bowl[2].

**The Case Against the Trade**

* **High Cost:** Acquiring Garrett would require a “massive haul”[1]. Some analysts believe the cost would be at least two first-round picks, a mid-round pick swap, and a player like AJ Epenesa or Kaiir Elam[3].
* **Epenesa’s Potential:** Epenesa is a replacement defensive end who started the entire year for the Bills[2]. Trading him would create a hole on the Bills’ defense.
* **Browns’ Reluctance:** The Browns have made it clear they have no intention of trading Garrett, at least not right now[2].

**Other Potential Suitors**

Besides the Bills, teams like the Washington Commanders, Chicago Bears, and Green Bay Packers may also be interested in Garrett[2][4][5].

**Fan Frenzy: Worth the Risk?**

The proposed trade has ignited a debate among fans[6]. Some believe Garrett is worth the high price tag, while others are hesitant to give up valuable assets for a single player.

Whether the Bills should pursue a trade for Garrett remains to be seen. However, the suggestion has sparked a lively discussion among fans about the team’s priorities and long-term strategy.

Related Posts

Mom of Eagles’ LB Haason Reddick describes son’s surreal journey to Super Bowl.

It will be a surreal moment for Raelakia Reddick when her son straps up his cleats and takes the field for Super Bowl LVII. “It really hasn’t…

Dalvin and James Cook: All About the NFL Brothers’ Bond On and Off the Field.

Dalvin Cook before the start of the game against the New York Giants at U.S. Bank Stadium on December 24, 2022 in Minneapolis, Minnesota. ; James Cook…

A detailed breakdown of every Kansas City Chiefs pick in the 2025 NFL Draft: When Mahomes has reason to smile.

Suffice it to say that Patrick Mahomes wasn’t sporting a big smile after Super Bowl LIX after he and the Kansas City Chiefs were thoroughly dominated by Philadelphia. Of…

BREAKING: Buccaneers select productive SMU defensive lineman in fifth round.

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers continue to stack up on defense, and now, they’ve brought in a defensive lineman to add to the ranks. The Buccaneers drafted Southern…

UPDATE: Buffalo Bills finalize 2025 NFL Draft with 9 rookies: Full view of team’s picks.

Round 1, Pick 30 — CB Maxwell Hairston, Kentucky The Bills had several needs, mostly on defense, coming into the 2025 NFL Draft. They needed to bring…

BREAKING: Chiefs face challenge as some draft picks struggle during defensive overhaul.

The Kansas City Chiefs provided defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo with a few new toys on day two of the NFL draft. The Kansas City Chiefs had a clear plan…