“Cardinals Eye Alcantara in Blockbuster Trade: New Ace Coming to St. Louis?”

In a move that could dramatically alter their pitching rotation, the St. Louis Cardinals are reportedly in pursuit of Miami Marlins ace Sandy Alcantara. This potential acquisition has ignited excitement among Cardinals fans and sparked debate about the team’s strategy for the 2025 season.

Alcantara: A Cardinal in the Making?

While a former St. Louis Cardinal hasn’t joined the team yet, there’s still speculation that pitcher Sandy Alcantara could still be headed to the Cardinals1. After debuting with the club in 2017, Alcantara posted 8 1/3 innings pitched for the Cardinals1. There is speculation that there will be a trade at some point this season to open up a spot for left-hander Quinn Matthews, who is considered to be one of the smartest players in baseball3.

The Cost of a Potential Ace

Acquiring Alcantara would likely require the Cardinals to part with some of their top prospects. MLB.com notes that thirteen of St. Louis’ Top 30 prospects have 2025 ETAs, including Quinn Mathews (No. 2), right-hander Tink Hence (No. 3), catcher Jimmy Crooks (No. 4), infielder Thomas Saggese (No. 5) and left-hander Cooper Hjerpe (No. 6)2.

Other Rotation Considerations

Several internal options could factor into the Cardinals’ rotation plans for 2025. Michael McGreevy has already proven he can pitch in the Majors, while healthy years from Hjerpe and Tekoah Roby could add to that depth2. Sem Robberse and Gordon Graceffo may also factor into the starting pitching conversation2.

Fan Excitement Mixed with Caution

Cardinals fans are eager to see their team improve its pitching staff. With names like Sonny Gray, Andre Pallante, Erick Fedde, Steven Matz, and Miles Mikolas set to be starting pitchers, change might be in order5.