The NASCAR world is buzzing, and not for the reasons Chase Elliott might hope. The Hendrick Motorsports star, known for his cool-headed driving and 2020 Cup Series championship, is once again in the hot seat—not for his performance on the track, but for his off-track demeanor. Fans have reignited the debate over Elliott’s so-called “box of tissues” personality, a jab that’s been thrown his way before, and it’s sparking a firestorm across social media and beyond.
It all started with a recent Instagram video where Elliott was asked for a bold take, something to stir the pot. Instead, the 29-year-old delivered a response so tame it could’ve been scripted by a librarian. “Fans were hoping for something juicy, maybe a little controversial,” one commenter lamented, “but he just gave us classic Chase.” That classic Chase, shaped by his father Bill Elliott’s drama-free legacy, has long been a point of pride for the driver. Bill, after all, holds the record for the most Most Popular Driver awards, a title Chase has claimed multiple times himself. But in 2025, that reserved charm is starting to wear thin for some.
The backlash isn’t new. Elliott’s been called out for being “boring” or not smiling enough, even after victories. “He’s got the personality of a box of tissues,” one fan quipped online, a sentiment echoed by others frustrated with his private, low-key vibe. Another wrote, “I get he likes his privacy, but give us *something* to work with!” The criticism has even spilled over to the Most Popular Driver award, with detractors arguing Elliott’s lack of flair makes him undeserving, despite his loyal fanbase.
But is this really a fair hit? Elliott’s supporters argue his focus is where it belongs: on racing. With 19 career wins and a Daytona 500 still in his sights, he’s hardly coasting. “Chase doesn’t need to be a clown for the cameras,” one fan countered. “He lets his driving do the talking.” Others point out the double standard—drivers like Ross Chastain catch flak for being *too* wild, while Elliott’s criticized for staying calm. In a sport where personalities range from brash to buttoned-up, why does Elliott’s approach feel like such a lightning rod?
The truth might lie in NASCAR’s evolving landscape. Today’s fans crave drama, soundbites, and viral moments, fueled by platforms like X and Instagram. Elliott’s preference for a quiet life—hunting, hanging with friends, staying out of the spotlight—clashes with that hunger for spectacle. Yet, there’s something refreshing about his authenticity. He’s not playing a character; he’s just Chase. Whether that’s a strength or a weakness depends on who’s watching.
As the season rolls on, the “box of tissues” jab will likely fade, but the conversation it’s sparked won’t. Is Elliott’s understated style a relic in a sport chasing headlines, or is it a reminder that substance can still trump showmanship? One thing’s certain: Chase Elliott’s not changing for anyone—and that might be the boldest statement of all.[](https://www.essentiallysports.com/nascar-news-chase-elliott-under-fire-once-again-with-his-box-of-tissues-personality-embarrassing-fans/)
