PFF Says 49ers QB Brock Purdy Deserves $60 Million Per Year—Is He Worth It?

The $60 Million Question

Brock Purdy has gone from being the final pick in the 2022 NFL Draft to potentially becoming one of the highest-paid quarterbacks in the league. Pro Football Focus (PFF) recently suggested that Purdy deserves a contract worth $60 million per year, putting him in the same financial tier as Dak Prescott. But does he truly warrant such a massive payday?

Purdy’s Performance: A Tale of Two Halves

There’s no denying Purdy has been an efficient and reliable quarterback for the 49ers. His ability to command Kyle Shanahan’s offense, make quick decisions, and distribute the ball effectively has been a key reason for San Francisco’s success. However, a deeper look at his performance in 2024 raises concerns.

In the first half of games, Purdy was impressive, throwing 12 touchdowns against just two interceptions. But in the second half, particularly in tight contests, his numbers dipped significantly—eight touchdowns and 10 interceptions. This pattern suggests that while he starts strong, he struggles under pressure when the game is on the line.

The 49ers’ Dilemma

San Francisco initially offered Purdy around $45 million per season, but reports indicate that his camp won’t settle for less than $60 million. With other stars like Nick Bosa, Deebo Samuel, and Christian McCaffrey on expensive contracts, the 49ers face a difficult decision. If they commit to Purdy at that price, it could limit their ability to strengthen the rest of the roster.

A Better Alternative?

Some analysts argue that the 49ers should explore other options rather than locking into an expensive long-term deal with Purdy. One bold suggestion is trading Purdy for a first-round pick and signing a veteran like Aaron Rodgers, who could be available at a lower price. While Rodgers is older, his experience and ability in high-pressure situations could provide an upgrade in the short term.

Should the 49ers Take the Risk?

Paying Purdy $60 million per year is a gamble. He has shown flashes of brilliance, but his inconsistency raises concerns about whether he’s truly an elite quarterback. If San Francisco believes he’s the long-term answer, they should pay him and build around him. If not, they must consider bold alternatives before making a financial commitment that could shape the franchise’s future.

The 49ers have a decision to make. Will they bet big on Purdy, or will they take a different path?