Aaron Judge is quite open about his deep affection for being a part of the New York Yankees. Each year at the MLB All-Star Game, the Yankees’ leader makes it a priority to engage with players from across the league—not just to build connections but to share what he believes is one of baseball’s greatest privileges: donning the iconic pinstripes in the Bronx.

“I try to speak to everyone, especially those who aren’t Yankees,” Judge remarked, “and explain just how unique this franchise is. And how incredible it is to perform in front of these fans.” Judge, who turned down a $400 million offer to remain in New York City, sees playing there as more than just about legacy or titles—it’s about the pressure, the passion, and the people.

It’s about supporters who arrive with high expectations every night, regardless of the day or the opponent, the same fans who recently directed their boos at now-rival Juan Soto. “They demand and anticipate the best from you every single night,” Judge stated. “It doesn’t matter if it’s a Monday game, a Tuesday game, or who we’re facing.

They expect you to go out there and win. They expect you to go out there and get a hit every time you’re at bat.” This intensity, he notes, is precisely why he opted to return to the Yankees when he reached free agency in the offseason. The expectations in New York might deter some players—but for Judge, they’re what makes it worthwhile.

“That’s another reason why I wanted to come back and play for the Yankees,” he explained. “It’s that expectation and that level of concentration you need to have every day. It’s truly one of a kind.” Judge has been with the Yankees since 2016, evolving from a much-anticipated prospect to the team captain and the face of the franchise.

Over the years, he has won over fans not only with his towering home runs and clutch performances but also with his dependable presence and composed leadership. Whether it’s advising rookies in the clubhouse or conversing with All-Stars from rival teams, he conducts himself as someone proud of his role—and eager to share what makes it exceptional.