In a move that underscores the rapidly shifting dynamics in Dallas, the Cowboys front office made a sobering announcement today: quarterback Dak Prescott’s starting position is officially “in jeopardy” if his performance does not show significant improvement heading into the 2025 preseason.

The announcement, delivered via team spokesperson and later confirmed by head coach Mike McCarthy, follows weeks of speculation after the team’s blockbuster signing of Aaron Rodgers, who joined the Cowboys on the largest contract in NFL history.

“Dak’s been a valued leader and competitor for this organization,” McCarthy said in a press briefing Tuesday morning. “But we are entering a new chapter. Expectations are higher than ever — and the position will be earned, not guaranteed.”

⏳ The Timeline: From Franchise Face to Uncertain Future

Prescott, 31, has been the Cowboys’ starting quarterback since 2016, compiling a career record of 73–47 with two Pro Bowl selections. However, postseason success has remained elusive, and inconsistent performances in critical moments have drawn criticism in recent years — especially after last season’s early playoff exit.

Complicating matters, Prescott is entering the final year of his current contract, and no long-term extension talks are currently underway, according to sources close to the team.

“We want to see leadership, consistency, and command of the offense,” said team executive Stephen Jones. “That applies to everyone — including Dak.”

🔥 The Rodgers Effect

Aaron Rodgers’ arrival in Dallas has dramatically shifted the quarterback conversation. At 41, Rodgers has made it clear that he didn’t come to Dallas to sit on the bench — and his contract gives him considerable influence over the offense’s design and execution.

According to insiders, the Cowboys coaching staff is preparing both Rodgers and Prescott for “true competition” this summer.

Rodgers, in his trademark calm but confident tone, offered only this:

“I’m here to help this team win. How we get there is up to the coaches. I’ll be ready.”

🧠 Behind the Scenes: What’s Driving the Decision?

Sources indicate the team’s growing concern centers around:

• Turnover ratio: Prescott threw a career-high 17 interceptions in 2023, and continued to struggle with reads under pressure.

• Leadership in crunch time: Internal evaluations showed diminished command during key moments late in games.

• Rodgers’ presence: The organization feels now is the time to push every player to deliver at a championship level — or risk being replaced.

📣 Fanbase Reactions: Divided and Emotional

Cowboys Nation is, predictably, split:

• Some fans are calling for Prescott to be benched immediately, citing years of “almost” seasons.

• Others defend Dak fiercely, pointing to his loyalty, toughness, and statistical success over nearly a decade.

“Dak deserves more respect than this,” tweeted one longtime fan.
“We’re chasing a Super Bowl — no more loyalty trophies,” responded another.

🏈 What Happens Now?

The Cowboys will begin mandatory minicamp in June, where all eyes will be on quarterback reps. If Prescott shows marked improvement, the starting job could remain his — at least to start the season. But any falter, even in preseason games, could trigger a monumental shift.

The coaching staff has not yet declared a Week 1 starter, and internal sources say both Rodgers and Prescott will take first-team snaps through training camp.

📉 Could a Trade Be Next?

If Rodgers wins the job outright, Prescott could become a valuable trade asset. Several quarterback-needy teams — including the Raiders, Commanders, and Panthers — are monitoring the situation closely.

His contract remains manageable for a one-year rental, and if Dallas chooses not to extend him, they may attempt to move him before the October trade deadline.

🎙️ Final Word from McCarthy

“We’re here to win. That’s the bottom line. Every player knows what’s expected. And that includes the quarterback position.”