Why Two Potential Lions Draft Picks Are ‘Risky Propositions’

Introduction: The Lions Eyeing EDGE Rushers in the 2025 NFL Draft

The Detroit Lions are looking to bolster their defense in the 2025 NFL Draft, particularly focusing on the EDGE rusher position. With the team needing to add pass-rushers who can consistently finish plays and sack the quarterback, the Lions have been linked to several defensive ends, including Mykel Williams from Georgia and Shemar Stewart from Texas A&M. Both players have garnered attention from analysts and draft pundits, but there are concerns that make them risky propositions for the Lions.

The Lions’ Need for Impactful EDGE Rushers

The Detroit Lions’ defense is in desperate need of dynamic EDGE rushers who can bring pressure to opposing quarterbacks. While veteran Marcus Davenport was re-signed for a one-year deal, the team’s plans include adding more young talent to their defensive line. With such a crucial need for pass-rushers, selecting the right players is vital to improving the defense and making a real impact in the upcoming season.

However, both Williams and Stewart—two prospects who have been frequently mocked to the Lions—come with certain areas of concern that could make their selection a gamble for the team.

Shemar Stewart: A Physical Specimen, but Pass-Rush Issues

Shemar Stewart is considered one of the most athletic defensive prospects in the 2025 draft. His size, strength, and raw athleticism are undeniable, making him a tantalizing prospect. However, there are significant concerns about his pass-rush ability, which could limit his immediate impact at the NFL level.

As Chris Trapasso of CBS Sports points out, Stewart’s pass-rush moves are underdeveloped, and despite his physical gifts, he has struggled to convert those skills into effective play on the field. His low pressure rate of 11.6% throughout his collegiate career is concerning, especially for a player expected to make an immediate impact as a first-round pick. While Stewart certainly has the potential to develop, it may take time for him to build his pass-rush arsenal and make a significant contribution to the Lions’ defense.

The Developmental Concerns: Stewart’s Lack of Pass-Rush Moves

Stewart’s lack of pass-rush moves is a critical concern for the Lions, who need someone who can contribute right away. As a workout warrior with exceptional physical talent, Stewart has shown flashes of brilliance, but those moments are few and far between. His development at the NFL level will require significant work on his pass-rush technique, and there is a risk that the Lions could be selecting a player who may take time to mature into a consistent force.

Mykel Williams: A High-Potential, Yet Underdeveloped Prospect

Another player the Lions have been linked to is Mykel Williams from Georgia. Recently mocked to Detroit by several draft analysts, Williams has potential but comes with his own set of concerns. Scouts have noted issues with his pad level as a rusher, which affects his ability to generate consistent power when engaging with offensive linemen.

Williams’ pass-rush arsenal has also been described as underdeveloped, and his explosiveness off the line of scrimmage has been called into question. As Trapasso explains, Williams tends to get too high when rushing the quarterback, which diminishes his ability to bull rush effectively. While he does show some awareness of using finesse moves, his first step is not explosive enough to consistently threaten offensive tackles in the NFL.

Williams’ Need for Development: The Path to Success

For Williams to be worthy of a first-round selection, he must develop a broader range of pass-rush moves to handle the high-caliber offensive tackles he will face in the NFL. His physical traits and potential are apparent, but whether he can develop into a consistent threat at the next level remains a question. For the Lions, taking Williams could mean investing in a player who needs significant coaching and refinement before making a tangible impact on the field.

Conclusion: High Ceiling, But Significant Risk

Both Shemar Stewart and Mykel Williams are incredibly talented players with undeniable physical tools. However, their underdeveloped pass-rush arsenals and certain technical flaws make them risky selections for the Detroit Lions, particularly in the early rounds of the 2025 NFL Draft. The Lions need EDGE rushers who can make an immediate impact, and while Stewart and Williams have the potential to develop into stars, their current limitations could hinder their ability to contribute right away.

If the Lions decide to go after these players, they will need to be prepared for a development-heavy process. While both players possess high ceilings, there are significant risks involved in selecting them, and Detroit’s front office will need to weigh the potential rewards against the time and effort required to unlock their full potential.