The Kansas City Chiefs have a decision to make regarding Joe Thuney’s position on their offensive line after his remarkable performance earned him the #1 Pro Football Focus (PFF) ranking among left tackles. Traditionally a left guard, Thuney was thrust into the left tackle role due to injuries, and his seamless transition left fans and analysts alike marveling at his versatility and reliability. The question now is whether the Chiefs should commit to him at left tackle or return him to his usual position.

Thuney’s adaptability has always been a cornerstone of his game. Known for his consistent technique and high football IQ, he proved capable of handling edge rushers and protecting Patrick Mahomes’ blind side with ease. His footwork, strength, and ability to read defensive schemes have been instrumental in his success. The Chiefs saw immediate benefits in pass protection, allowing Mahomes more time to make plays, which is critical to their high-octane offense.

However, moving Thuney to left tackle permanently comes with implications. At left guard, Thuney is among the league’s elite, providing a stabilizing presence in the interior line. The Chiefs could risk weakening their overall line by shifting him outside long-term. Replacing an interior lineman of his caliber isn’t a simple task, as the chemistry and cohesion of the line are vital to success.

The decision also hinges on the development of younger players and the availability of other tackles. If a promising player like Donovan Smith or another prospect can step up, Thuney could return to his natural position. Additionally, with the NFL Draft and free agency always offering new opportunities, the Chiefs could explore adding depth to maintain their line’s dominance without relying exclusively on Thuney’s versatility.

Ultimately, keeping Joe Thuney at left tackle should depend on how the Chiefs’ offensive line performs as a unit. His stellar PFF ranking highlights his ability to rise to any challenge, but the team’s success relies on maximizing talent across all positions. Whether at left tackle or left guard, Thuney has proven to be an invaluable asset, ensuring Mahomes remains upright and the Chiefs’ offense stays one of the most feared in the league. Balancing immediate needs with long-term planning will be key as Kansas City aims to maintain its Super Bowl contention.