Steelers Eye Blockbuster Trade for Myles Garrett: “Best Pass Rush Duo Ever” or Fool’s Gold?

The Pittsburgh Steelers are predicted to make a splash in the 2025 offseason, potentially trading for Cleveland Browns All-Pro edge rusher Myles Garrett and pairing him with T.J. Watt to form what some are calling the “best pass rush duo in NFL History.”[1] But would acquiring Garrett truly elevate the Steelers to Super Bowl contenders, or would the price be too steep, hindering their ability to address other pressing needs?

**Garrett in the Steel City: A Defensive Nightmare for Opponents?**

The hypothetical trade could involve the Steelers giving up significant draft capital. While pairing Garrett with Watt would undoubtedly create a formidable pass-rushing tandem, the Steelers have other needs to address[1].

**Weighing the Cost: Is Garrett Worth the Gamble?**

Acquiring Garrett would require the Steelers to part ways with valuable draft picks, potentially limiting their ability to build depth and address other crucial positions[1]. The Steelers also need to consider their quarterback situation[1].

**Areas the Steelers Need to Improve:**

* **Wide Receiver:** The Steelers need to add a wide receiver or two[5].
* **Offensive Line:** Evan Neal possesses raw talent at the tackle position that could significantly improve the Steelers’ offensive line in 2025[1]. The Steelers could also focus on acquiring a skilled wide receiver[6].
* **Cornerback:** The Steelers may consider trading for cornerback Jamel Dean[3].

**Social Media Erupts: Divided Opinions**

The prospect of Garrett joining the Steelers has ignited a passionate debate among fans on social media:

* **Excitement:** Some believe that a dominant pass rush would transform the Steelers’ defense into an unstoppable force, paving the way for a Super Bowl run.
* **Skepticism:** Others are wary of sacrificing valuable draft picks and cap space for a single player, especially when the team has other pressing needs.

**Trading Away Key Players?**

To make room for Garrett, the Steelers might consider trading some current players. Potential trade candidates include:

* **George Pickens:** Pickens’ talent is undeniable; however, the drama that comes with him is less than ideal[2].
* **Cameron Heyward:** It may be time to take trade calls for Cam Heyward[2].

**Conclusion: A Defining Decision for the Steelers**

Trading for Myles Garrett would represent a bold and potentially franchise-altering move for the Pittsburgh Steelers. The potential reward is a historically dominant pass rush and a Super Bowl breakthrough. However, the cost in terms of draft capital and potential roster turnover could be significant, potentially hindering their ability to sustain long-term success. Whether the Steelers ultimately decide to pursue this blockbuster trade will depend on their assessment of the risks and rewards, and their confidence in their ability to build a championship-caliber team around a dominant pass rush.