San Francisco 49ers Trade Jordan Mason: A Surprising Move or Smart Business?

A Trade That Shocked the Fanbase When news broke that the San Francisco 49ers were trading running back Jordan Mason for a future sixth-round pick and a late-round pick swap in 2025, it sent shockwaves through the fanbase. Many questioned the logic behind the move, especially given Mason’s strong performances in 2024. With multiple 100-yard games under his belt, why would the 49ers part ways with him for such a seemingly low return?

Uncertainty Surrounding Christian McCaffrey’s Durability One of the biggest concerns among fans is whether the 49ers can count on Christian McCaffrey to stay healthy for all 17 regular-season games in 2025. While McCaffrey remains one of the most dynamic playmakers in the league, his injury history raises doubts. Trading away a reliable backup like Mason leaves many wondering if the 49ers are taking an unnecessary risk heading into the new season.

Confidence in Isaac Guerendo? Another possible explanation for the trade is the team’s confidence in rookie running back Isaac Guerendo, their fourth-round pick out of Louisville in 2024. If the coaching staff believes Guerendo can step up and fill the backup role behind McCaffrey, then moving Mason makes more sense. However, counting on a rookie to perform at a high level without NFL experience is always a gamble.

A Calculated Strategy for Future Draft Capital According to 49ers insider David Lombardi, this trade aligns perfectly with San Francisco’s long-term strategy of accumulating draft assets. The organization has a history of finding key contributors in the later rounds, including Dre Greenlaw, George Kittle, Talanoa Hufanga, and Deommodore Lenoir—all former fifth-round picks. Even Elijah Mitchell, who rushed for nearly 1,000 yards as a rookie, was a sixth-round selection.

By acquiring an additional fifth-round pick in 2025 and a sixth-round pick in 2026, the 49ers are positioning themselves to continue their trend of drafting and developing impact players. The team is known for its ability to identify hidden gems, and this trade gives them more opportunities to do so.

The Irony of Mason’s Departure Ironically, the 49ers didn’t even use a draft pick to acquire Mason in the first place. He joined the team as an undrafted free agent out of Georgia Tech and worked his way up the depth chart through sheer determination. His rise was a testament to his work ethic, and in 2024, he took full advantage of his opportunities, delivering impressive performances.

Now, with an extra draft pick in 2026 and a chance to move up in 2025, the 49ers have the opportunity to draft their next hidden gem—whether it be another Greenlaw, Kittle, Hufanga, Lenoir, or even Mason himself.

Will the 49ers Regret This Move? The biggest risk in this trade is what happens if McCaffrey suffers an injury. Losing a reliable backup like Mason could put pressure on the team’s rushing attack. However, if Guerendo or another back steps up, the trade could ultimately be viewed as a win for the 49ers.

With a strong track record of success in the later rounds, San Francisco is betting on its ability to replace Mason and maintain a high level of play. Whether that gamble pays off will depend on how well their new additions perform in 2025 and beyond.