The debate over whether Justin Fields should be the Pittsburgh Steelers’ starting quarterback in 2025 hinges on various factors, including his performance in the previous season, team dynamics, and the potential for future development.

Performance Review

In 2024, Justin Fields started six games for the Steelers, achieving a 4-2 record while throwing ten touchdowns. His completion rate was a respectable 65.8%, indicating a solid performance given the circumstances he faced. Fields’ ability to adapt to an offense primarily designed for Russell Wilson suggests he has untapped potential that could be fully realized with a system tailored to his strengths.

Team Considerations

The Steelers are at a crossroads regarding their quarterback situation. With both Fields and Wilson entering free agency, team president Art Rooney II has expressed a preference for retaining one of them but acknowledges that it is unlikely both will return. Fields is younger than Wilson, which could provide the Steelers with a higher upside and longer-term stability at the quarterback position. However, there are concerns about Fields’ chemistry with key players like wide receiver George Pickens. Some insiders believe that a lack of rapport between them could influence the decision to move on from Fields. Despite this, many within the organization feel comfortable with Fields as the starter, recognizing his athleticism and potential for growth.

Financial Implications

The financial aspect also plays a crucial role in this decision. The Steelers are reportedly looking for a “reasonable” contract for Fields, which could align well with their budgetary constraints. Spotrac estimates his market value at around $6.4 million for one year, making him an attractive option compared to other quarterbacks who may demand higher salaries.

Conclusion

In summary, while there are valid arguments both for and against Justin Fields as the Steelers’ starting quarterback in 2025, the consensus leans toward him being a viable option. His demonstrated ability to win games, combined with his youth and potential for development, makes him an appealing choice as Pittsburgh seeks to establish stability at the quarterback position post-Ben Roethlisberger. Ultimately, if the Steelers can negotiate a reasonable contract with Fields, he should be given the opportunity to lead the team into the new season.