Vinnie Pasquantino, the Kansas City Royals’ first baseman, has been a figure of both promise and frustration since he arrived in the major leagues. His journey has been marked by flashes of brilliance, but also by recurring injuries and inconsistency that have prevented him from fully realizing his potential. As the 2025 season progresses, it’s becoming clear that Pasquantino’s legacy — the baggage he carries — may come back to haunt the Royals one last time.
Drafted by the Royals in 2019 from Old Dominion University, Pasquantino quickly became a fan favorite thanks to his raw power and hitting ability. Despite being a late-round pick (11th round), he impressed in the minors and earned his major league debut in 2022. His offensive potential was evident, and Royals fans hoped he would become a cornerstone of their lineup for years to come.
In 2025, Pasquantino has shown signs of fulfilling that promise. After a slow start to the season, he caught fire, slashing .359/.404/.531 over a 36-game stretch since April 30. He became the first Royal to hit double-digit home runs this season and was named the American League Player of the Week in early June, thanks to an incredible six-game stretch where he hit .500 with two home runs and seven RBIs.
Despite his offensive surge, Pasquantino’s career has been plagued by injuries. In 2023, he underwent right shoulder surgery that sidelined him for three months. Last season, he missed the final month with a broken right thumb, only returning for the postseason after a rigorous rehab. This spring, a right hamstring strain threatened to derail his preparation for the 2025 season, though he was fortunately cleared to play before Opening Day.
Pasquantino himself has admitted that staying healthy is one of his biggest challenges and goals. “Not being healthy for a full season so far in my career is one of the things that keeps me up at night,” he said. This ongoing battle with injuries raises concerns about his ability to be a reliable everyday player for the Royals.
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/24728668/usa_today_20791431.jpg)
The Royals have been rebuilding and aiming to become contenders, and having a dependable power hitter at first base is crucial. Pasquantino’s offensive bursts have provided hope, but his injury history and inconsistency create uncertainty. The team’s success may hinge on whether he can stay on the field and maintain his hot streaks.
If Pasquantino’s injuries resurface or his production dips, the Royals could find themselves lacking the offensive punch they need. This “baggage” threatens to haunt the team, especially as they face tough competition in the American League Central and beyond.
Royals fans have shown patience and support for Pasquantino, appreciating his work ethic and flashes of brilliance. Manager Matt Quatraro has praised his recent hot streak, noting that Pasquantino has been swinging the bat well for weeks. Yet, the underlying worry remains: can he stay healthy and consistent?
The organization must balance nurturing Pasquantino’s talent with managing his physical limitations. How they handle this situation could define the Royals’ trajectory in the coming seasons.
As the 2025 season continues, Pasquantino’s legacy is at a crossroads. Will he overcome his injury woes and become the reliable slugger the Royals envisioned? Or will his “baggage” — the injuries and inconsistency — ultimately limit his impact and come back to haunt the team one last time?
The answer will shape not only Pasquantino’s career but also the Royals’ hopes of returning to postseason prominence.
Conclusion
Vinnie Pasquantino’s story is one of talent, resilience, and unfulfilled potential. His recent offensive surge offers a glimpse of what could be, but his history of injuries and inconsistency casts a long shadow. For the Royals, managing this delicate balance is critical. Pasquantino’s legacy — and the team’s future — may well hinge on whether he can finally stay healthy and deliver consistently, or if his baggage will haunt Kansas City one final time.
