Why, Even After Being Eliminated from the Playoffs, the Cowboys Will Still Start Cooper Rush Over Trey Lance

The Dallas Cowboys, known for their storied history and passionate fanbase, find themselves in an unusual position this season. Despite being eliminated from playoff contention, the team has decided to start Cooper Rush over Trey Lance in their remaining games. This decision has sparked debate among fans and analysts alike. However, a closer examination reveals several compelling reasons behind this move.

1. Stability and Familiarity

Cooper Rush has been with the Cowboys organization since 2017, barring a brief stint with the New York Giants. Over the years, he has developed a strong understanding of the team’s offensive system. Rush’s familiarity with the playbook and rapport with teammates provide a level of stability that is crucial, even in games with no postseason implications. The coaching staff likely values this stability as they aim to maintain a sense of continuity heading into the offseason.

In contrast, Trey Lance, who was acquired from the San Francisco 49ers earlier this season, is still acclimating to the Cowboys’ system. His limited practice reps and game experience with Dallas make it challenging to fully evaluate his potential in live-action scenarios. Starting Lance prematurely could lead to misunderstandings and mistakes that might hinder his development.

2. Preserving Confidence and Development

Trey Lance’s journey in the NFL has been tumultuous. Drafted third overall by the 49ers in 2021, injuries and inconsistent performances have limited his playing time. The Cowboys’ coaching staff may believe that throwing Lance into a starting role without adequate preparation could damage his confidence.

Instead, the team appears to be taking a measured approach to Lance’s development. Allowing him to observe and learn from the sidelines while gradually increasing his involvement in practice and game situations could set him up for long-term success.

3. Showcasing Cooper Rush for Trade Value

Another factor to consider is the potential trade value of Cooper Rush. As a reliable backup quarterback who has stepped in effectively during Dak Prescott’s absences, Rush has demonstrated his ability to manage games and lead the team to victory. By starting him in the remaining games, the Cowboys have an opportunity to showcase his skills to other teams that may be in the market for a dependable backup or a bridge starter.

With the Cowboys likely committed to Prescott as their franchise quarterback and Lance as a developmental prospect, moving Rush in the offseason could free up cap space and potentially yield draft capital or other assets.

4. Maintaining Competitive Integrity

Even though the Cowboys are out of playoff contention, the organization’s culture and reputation demand that they continue to compete at a high level. Cooper Rush’s experience and poise give the team the best chance to remain competitive in their remaining games. This not only preserves the integrity of the competition but also respects fans who expect the team to give its best effort, regardless of the stakes.

5. Trey Lance’s Future Role

Ultimately, the Cowboys acquired Trey Lance with the future in mind. His athleticism and potential make him an intriguing prospect, but he is far from a finished product. The team’s long-term plan likely involves extensive offseason work to tailor the offense to his strengths and give him ample opportunities to earn a role.

For now, starting Cooper Rush allows the Cowboys to focus on ending the season on a strong note while ensuring that Lance’s development is handled with care.

Conclusion

The decision to start Cooper Rush over Trey Lance, even after being eliminated from playoff contention, reflects the Cowboys’ strategic priorities. Stability, player development, trade value considerations, competitive integrity, and long-term planning all play a role in this choice. While some may view it as a conservative move, it underscores the organization’s commitment to building a sustainable future while respecting the present. Cowboys fans will have to wait a bit longer to see what Trey Lance can bring to the table, but this measured approach could pay dividends in the seasons to come.