Why the NY Giants Might Want to Trade for 49ers QB Brock Purdy

A Desperate Search for a Quarterback

The New York Giants are in a precarious position. After a disastrous 2024 season, they are still searching for a reliable quarterback to lead their franchise. Daniel Jones has failed to prove himself as a long-term solution, and while the team holds the third overall pick in the upcoming draft, they may miss out on the top two quarterback prospects—Cam Ward and Shedeur Sanders. This leaves them with a difficult decision: gamble on a less highly rated rookie, try to convince a veteran like Aaron Rodgers to join them, or explore a blockbuster trade.

One name that has emerged as a potential target is San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy. Despite his success with the 49ers, contract demands and team priorities may push him onto the trading block. If that happens, the Giants might have a compelling reason to make a move.

The 49ers’ Dilemma

While the 49ers want to keep Purdy, recent reports suggest he is seeking a massive contract—potentially around $60 million per season. This would make him the second-highest-paid player in the NFL, behind only Dak Prescott. Given San Francisco’s roster construction and cap constraints, they may not be willing to meet that demand.

If the 49ers decide to move on, a trade with the Giants could make sense. One potential scenario being discussed is Purdy and the 11th overall pick going to New York in exchange for the Giants’ third overall selection. This would allow San Francisco to reset at quarterback while acquiring a top-tier non-quarterback prospect such as Travis Hunter or Abdul Carter.

Should the Giants Make the Trade?

The Giants’ front office faces a difficult question: Is Brock Purdy worth the investment? Trading for him would mean not only giving up valuable draft capital but also committing to a massive contract extension.

On one hand, Purdy has already proven he can lead a talented team deep into the playoffs. He possesses excellent decision-making skills, poise under pressure, and the ability to operate in a structured offense. Unlike a rookie quarterback, he wouldn’t need years of development—he could step in and immediately elevate the Giants’ offense.

However, there are risks involved. Purdy has benefited from playing in a well-designed system under Kyle Shanahan, surrounded by elite playmakers and a dominant defense. Would he be as effective without those advantages in New York? Additionally, if the Giants commit to Purdy and he doesn’t perform at a high level, they could find themselves in a financial nightmare similar to what they experienced with Daniel Jones.

A High-Stakes Decision

This is not just about whether Purdy is a good quarterback—it’s about whether he’s worth the cost. The Giants must decide if they are willing to sacrifice draft capital and financial flexibility to acquire him. Meanwhile, the 49ers must weigh whether moving on from their starting quarterback is the right move for their franchise’s long-term success.

With the draft approaching and quarterback-needy teams scrambling for solutions, the next few weeks could determine the fate of both organizations. Will the Giants make a bold move and trade for Brock Purdy, or will they opt for another path? One thing is certain—this decision will shape the future of both teams for years to come.