The Fall of the 49ers: Analyzing the Struggles of the 2024-25 Season
A Season of Setbacks
The San Francisco 49ers’ 2024-25 campaign was nothing short of a disappointment. Ending the season with a 6-11 record, the team fell far below expectations. Injuries plagued the roster, particularly on defense, and their once-dominant presence was reduced to a shadow of its former self. Dre Greenlaw’s torn Achilles was a critical blow, but the problems extended beyond injuries. The defense lacked cohesion, direction, and the productivity needed to compete at the highest level. Fans and analysts alike agree: the team needs a fresh spark—or perhaps a familiar one.
The Call for Robert Saleh
Following the dismissal of defensive coordinator Nick Sorensen, a groundswell of support has emerged for the return of Robert Saleh. As the defensive coordinator for the 49ers from 2017 to 2020, Saleh built one of the most formidable units in the NFL. Under his leadership, the 49ers boasted top-five finishes in yards allowed per game during his final two seasons. Now, with his stint as head coach of the New York Jets concluded, fans are eager to see him restore the 49ers’ defensive identity.
Reports suggest that San Francisco management is prepared to offer Saleh a lucrative deal to make him the highest-paid defensive coordinator in the league. However, his potential return hinges on developments in Jacksonville.
The Jacksonville Factor
Robert Saleh remains in contention for the Jacksonville Jaguars’ head coaching vacancy, adding complexity to the 49ers’ plans. Saleh recently completed a second interview with the Jaguars, but Tampa Bay Buccaneers offensive coordinator Liam Coen has emerged as the leading candidate for the job. According to Rick Stroud of the Tampa Bay Times, “there is a growing belief that it’s Coen’s job to lose.”
If Coen secures the position, Saleh’s head coaching opportunities for the upcoming season could narrow, making a return to San Francisco increasingly likely. The 49ers offer familiarity, a supportive environment, and the chance for Saleh to reclaim his reputation as one of the league’s premier defensive minds.
Why Saleh Makes Sense for San Francisco
San Francisco provides a unique opportunity for Robert Saleh. It’s the organization where he built his legacy, leading a defense that struck fear into opponents across the league. Returning to the 49ers would not only allow Saleh to reestablish his defensive philosophy but also provide the team with the direction and leadership it desperately needs.
The timing aligns perfectly. With Jacksonville focusing on developing quarterback Trevor Lawrence and prioritizing offensive leadership, Saleh may not fit their long-term vision. For the 49ers, however, he is an ideal match.
The Path to Redemption
The 49ers’ defense allowed an alarming 25.6 points per game last season, ranking among the league’s worst. For a team with championship aspirations, this is unacceptable. Head coach Kyle Shanahan and the organization must take decisive action to rebuild the defensive unit and restore their winning identity.
Robert Saleh’s potential return could mark the beginning of a new chapter for the 49ers. His ability to inspire players, implement innovative schemes, and adapt to challenges would provide the stability and direction the team sorely lacks.
What’s Next for the 49ers?
Whether or not Saleh returns, one thing is clear: the 49ers must address their defensive shortcomings to reclaim their position as NFC contenders. With the right moves in the offseason—beginning with the defensive coordinator role—they can chart a path back to prominence.
Conclusion
The 2024-25 season was a humbling experience for the San Francisco 49ers, but it also presents an opportunity for growth. Bringing back Robert Saleh could be the spark that reignites the team’s championship aspirations. As the offseason unfolds, fans eagerly await the decisions that will shape the future of the franchise. Will Saleh return to the Bay Area and lead the defense back to glory? Time will tell, but the potential is undeniable.
