The Boston baseball world is in uproar tonight after Red Sox manager Alex Cora made eyebrow-raising comments regarding rumors that Fernando Tatís Jr. — the electric but controversial Padres star — could be a future target for Boston.

Speaking to reporters during a pre-game press scrum, Cora was asked directly about the swirling speculation that Boston may pursue Tatís if he becomes available via trade or free agency. Rather than sidestepping, the usually composed manager gave an unexpectedly blunt assessment.

“Look, he’s talented — no one’s questioning that,” Cora said. “But talent without discipline? That’s not what we build around here.”

He continued,

“We’ve worked hard to build a clubhouse with accountability. I’m not saying no outright, but… we’re very careful with who we bring into this culture.”

The comment, especially Cora’s use of the phrase “talented but flawed,” spread like wildfire across social media, with #LetTatísPlay and #CoraOutOfLine trending within the hour. Many fans felt that the manager was publicly shaming a player who has already served his suspension and shown signs of maturity and growth since returning to the field.

Tatís, who was suspended 80 games in 2022 for violating MLB’s performance-enhancing drug policy, has since become one of the most dynamic outfielders in the game — both praised for his elite athleticism and still haunted by past mistakes.

“This is exactly why Boston never lands guys like this,” one Red Sox fan wrote on X. “Tatís made a mistake, owned it, and came back better. What more do you want?”

Others, however, defended Cora’s stance, citing Boston’s recent emphasis on character, clubhouse chemistry, and long-term leadership.

“You can’t bring in chaos to a young roster trying to rebuild,” another fan posted. “Cora’s just being honest — and smart.”

While neither the Red Sox nor Tatís Jr.’s camp have confirmed any official talks, MLB insiders say Boston has long admired his skillset. Whether this public moment burns a bridge or simply fans the flames of speculation remains to be seen.

For now, one thing is certain: Alex Cora’s comments have sparked a firestorm — and the Tatís-to-Boston dream may be slipping further out of reach.