In a move that has shocked fans and reignited debate across the sports world, New York Yankees rising star Ben Rice is reportedly facing a season-long ban from Major League Baseball due to his outspoken support for players kneeling during flag ceremonies.
According to multiple sources close to the league, Rice’s public defense of teammate Carlos Mendoza—who knelt during the national anthem earlier this month—has drawn the ire of MLB executives and certain ownership groups. While Mendoza was fined but not suspended, Rice’s continued vocal support and refusal to back down in interviews and on social media has escalated the situation dramatically.
Rice, 25, had recently emerged as a breakout talent in the Yankees lineup, earning praise for his discipline at the plate and leadership in the clubhouse. But now, his future in baseball is in serious jeopardy. A preliminary ruling from the MLB disciplinary committee, leaked early Wednesday morning, recommends a full-season suspension for “conduct deemed detrimental to the integrity of the league.”
Fans and analysts are split. Supporters of Rice argue that the punishment is a blatant overreach and an attempt to silence players who speak out on social issues. “This is 2025, not 1955,” tweeted former MLB All-Star Dexter Fowler. “Ben Rice is being punished not for what he did, but for what he believes. That’s dangerous.”
Others, however, see Rice’s actions as a distraction to the team and disrespectful to the traditions of the league. “Players should honor the anthem and the flag. That’s not political, that’s just basic respect,” said one anonymous front office official from an American League team.
The Yankees have yet to issue an official statement, though insiders say the front office is “deeply disappointed” with the league’s decision and is considering an appeal on Rice’s behalf. Several of Rice’s teammates, including captain Aaron Judge, have privately expressed outrage and are reportedly considering a team-wide demonstration during the next home game.
The situation is quickly spiraling into one of the most politically charged controversies in MLB history, with parallels being drawn to the NFL’s treatment of Colin Kaepernick nearly a decade ago.
As of now, Rice remains on the Yankees roster but has been held out of all team activities pending the final decision from the league office. A formal announcement from MLB is expected within the next 48 hours.
Whether Ben Rice will suit up again in pinstripes this season—or ever again—remains an open and deeply polarizing question.
